M. Karen Kilgore
M. Karen Kilgore is a seasoned attorney and partner at Cuddy & McCarthy, LLP, based in New Mexico, where she handles a broad spectrum of litigation and advocacy work. In her role at the firm, she is often involved in high-stakes matters spanning civil rights, employment law, constitutional law, commercial disputes, and public sector issues. She brings to her cases a sharp analytical mind, extensive trial experience, and a reputation for crafting creative legal strategies.
Over the course of her career, Kilgore has built a practice that bridges private and public law issues, frequently engaging in regulatory, administrative, and constitutional matters on behalf of governmental entities, institutions, and private clients. Her work often involves navigating complex interfaces between statutory schemes and fundamental rights, such as civil liberties, employment protections, and public accountability. In doing so, she strives not only to secure favorable outcomes for clients but to shape clearer, fairer frameworks through her litigation.
Beyond her casework, Kilgore is known for her leadership, mentorship, and commitment to the legal community. She serves as a guide for younger attorneys, models rigorous preparation and ethical advocacy, and contributes to her firm’s strategic direction. Her reputation among peers is one of professionalism, tenacity, and integrity—qualities she brings to even the most technically demanding and socially consequential cases.
• Tulane University - Bachelor of Arts (B.A.), English
• University of Oklahoma College of Law - Doctor of Law (J.D.)
• President, Board of Directors, Santa Fe Opera Guild: 2003 – 2004
• President, Equal Access to Justice: 2022-2025; Board Member 2020-2022
• Center for Civic Values (High School Mock Trial) Board, Treasurer
• Mexico Bar Association
• American Inns of Court
What do you attribute your success to?
I attribute my success to longevity and hard work. Over the years, I’ve learned that consistent effort, perseverance, and a genuine commitment to growth make the greatest difference. Staying dedicated through challenges and maintaining a long-term perspective has allowed me to build meaningful results and lasting relationships in my field.
What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?
My advice to young women entering this industry is to find a mentor and move forward with confidence. Having someone to guide you, challenge you, and share their experience can make all the difference in your professional growth. Learn as much as you can, trust your abilities, and don’t be afraid to take up space — every step you take builds the foundation for your success.
What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?
The values most important to me, both professionally and personally, are being present, honest, and hardworking. I believe in showing up fully — giving my attention and energy to the task or person in front of me. Honesty guides how I communicate and make decisions, while hard work reflects my commitment to excellence and integrity in everything I do. Together, these values shape how I lead, collaborate, and live each day.