Alison McCarty
Alison McCarty is a distinguished judge serving on the Summit County Court of Common Pleas, General Division, in Akron, Ohio. With over 17 years on the bench, she presides over a wide range of felony criminal and civil cases, emphasizing professionalism, public service, and rehabilitation-focused programs that reduce recidivism. Alison also serves as Administrative Judge, overseeing court operations and providing leadership in docket management and court administration.
Before her judicial appointment, Alison built a 38-year legal career, beginning as a judicial attorney for an appellate judge and then serving a decade in the Summit County Prosecutor’s Office. There, she specialized in prosecuting felony cases involving child physical and sexual abuse, as well as sexual assault, earning recognition for her work on high-profile cases such as State of Ohio v. Douglas Prade (1998). Her dedication to victims and at-risk children has remained a cornerstone of her professional focus throughout her career.
Alison holds a Bachelor’s degree in English from Wheaton College and a JD from Wake Forest University School of Law, with further leadership training through the Harvard Law School Judicial Executive Leadership Program. She is actively involved in professional organizations including the Akron Bar Association, Ohio State Bar Association, and the Christian Legal Society, and serves on multiple committees addressing child welfare and domestic violence. Her accolades include the University of Akron Urban Light Award and joint recognition from the Akron Police Department and Children’s Services Board for advocacy on behalf of abused and at-risk children.
• Ohio Supreme Court Certified as Presiding Judge of ReEntry Court
• Wake Forest University School of Law- J.D.
• Wheaton College- B.A.
• University of Akron Urban Light Award
• Committee Chair of the Year Award- twice
• Leadership Award
• Akron Bar Association
• Ohio State Bar Association
• Christian Legal Society
• Scanlon/Bell American Inns of Court
• Child Fatality Review Committee
• Ohio Sexual Assault Coalition
• Summit County Sexual Assault Coalition
• Domestic Violence Task Force
• Ed Duvall Award
• Ohio High School Students Mock Trial Competition (ran committee for 15 years)
What do you attribute your success to?
I attribute my success to a combination of dedication, responsibility, and a commitment to serving others. Nearly four decades in the legal profession—from serving as a judicial attorney and county prosecutor to my current role as Administrative Judge—have taught me that diligence, compassion, and integrity are essential in protecting the vulnerable and upholding justice. Continuous learning, mentorship, and a focus on accountability and rehabilitation have guided my career and shaped the way I lead both in the courtroom and in the broader community.
What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?
The best career advice I ever received came from Judge Brenda Burnham Unruh, who taught me the importance of leading with integrity and making a meaningful impact through every decision.
What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?
I would say, when it comes to deciding what kind of lawyer you want to be, because there are so many different areas, you should not limit yourself by what you think you're capable of. You should explore a lot of different options, and maybe you'll be able to expand your skill set. I mean, I would say that I'm somewhat of an introvert, but I decided I was interested in trying cases, so I basically learned the skill set of being comfortable speaking in public, and advocating, and building a case. People kind of laugh at me now when I tell them I'm an introvert, but you don't have to limit yourself by what you think you're only capable of. Keep an open mind, and you can always teach yourself skills as well.
What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?
We see a lot of interpersonal violence in families, and there's also a lot of senseless gun violence. That's a real struggle. Why so many young people, rather than resolving disputes through conversation, or even verbal confrontation, or even a physical confrontation like fistfighting, it seems they move to guns, which becomes lethal quickly. There seems to be a lacking of coping mechanisms for options of how to resolve things.
What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?
I have learned to compartmentalize what I do here at the office, so after all these many years, I have learned to put away what happened at work and try not to take it home with you, especially what I see out in the courtroom and all the human misery that I can see. There's not a lot of joy in the court. So I have learned to put that aside and try to focus on myself and my family when I'm not in the courthouse. I also make exercise a priority because it's so important to my mental health, just to have that release of energy. When I started my third year as administrative judge, it was kind of overwhelming and I was working a lot of hours and wasn't working out as much as I needed to. So I adapted that so that I'm making it more of a priority.
Locations
Summit County Court of Common Pleas- General Division
209 South High Street, 3rd Floor, Akron, OH 44308
Call