I earned trust by leading with authenticity, continuous learning, and a client-first mindset, striving to deliver consistency and results in every interaction.
Jessica Soley · In Her Own Words
Her Story
About Jessica
Jessica Soley is an insurance professional with a strong foundation in customer service, sales, underwriting, and commercial lines within the Property & Casualty industry.
She began her career in healthcare as a licensed massage therapist before an injury required her to pivot and redefine her professional path. That transition led her into insurance, where she quickly discovered a passion for helping clients understand coverage, manage risk, and protect what matters most—especially within the complexities of commercial insurance. Jessica’s entry into the industry came with notable challenges. While navigating limited support early in her journey, she worked diligently to earn her Michigan Property & Casualty license—ultimately achieving success through persistence, resilience, and determination after multiple attempts. She went on to build a strong foundation at a major national carrier, where she consistently exceeded performance expectations, advanced into an underwriting role, and gained valuable experience across commercial lines. In addition to her underwriting responsibilities, she contributed to the development of new hires through training support, earning recognition for her knowledge, consistency, and reliability.
Today, Jessica continues to grow her career with Blakemore Insurance Agency, where she serves as an Associate Agent working with Farm Bureau. In this role, she focuses on building strong client relationships, expanding her professional network, and delivering clear, dependable guidance on both personal and commercial coverage solutions. She is now preparing for the next chapter—transitioning into agency ownership—where she will lead with the same commitment to professionalism, mentorship, and client-focused service that has defined her career. Jessica is driven by a passion for helping clients make confident decisions while building a successful, purpose-driven business.
Her Interview
Ten minutes with Jessica
01What do you attribute your success to?
I attribute my success to a combination of persistence, resilience, and the people who support me every day. There were a lot of moments early on where things didn’t come easy—especially transitioning into a new industry and working to earn my license after multiple attempts. But I made a decision that no matter how many setbacks I faced, I wasn’t going to quit on myself. My mindset played a big role too. I’ve always been willing to learn, to ask questions, and to keep growing—even when I didn’t have much guidance. I stayed consistent and chose to push through challenges rather than avoid them. But honestly, a huge part of my success comes from my why—my family. My significant other and my kids are my biggest motivation. They’ve supported me through the long hours, the uncertainty, and the moments where things felt overwhelming. Everything I’ve built, and everything I’m working toward, is for them.
At the end of the day, my success has really been about showing up, staying committed, and continuing to grow—not just for myself, but for the life I want to create for my family.
02What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?
The best career advice I’ve ever received was to bet on myself—even when I didn’t feel ready. Early on, I spent a lot of time questioning whether I had enough experience or whether I was truly prepared to take the next step. But I learned that growth doesn’t happen when you’re comfortable—it happens when you’re willing to step into the unknown and figure it out along the way. That advice really stuck with me, especially during some pivotal moments in my career—like transitioning into insurance, pushing through the challenges of getting licensed, and now preparing for agency ownership. I’ve realized that you don’t have to have everything figured out—you just have to be willing to show up, stay consistent, and trust that you’ll grow into the person the opportunity requires. That mindset has made all the difference for me, both professionally and personally.
03What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?
You don’t have to wait for the perfect moment or for everything to make sense—because the truth is, that moment may never come. Growth doesn’t happen when everything is clear; it happens when you’re willing to move forward anyway.
If you feel that pull—that desire to do something more, to become something more—I truly believe you should listen to it. That’s your intuition speaking, and that’s often where the most meaningful growth begins.
04What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?
One of the biggest challenges in the insurance field right now is earning and keeping clients’ trust in a market that’s constantly changing. With rising premiums, shifting underwriting guidelines, and increased competition, clients are asking more questions and expecting more value. It really pushes you to stay knowledgeable, communicate clearly, and truly advocate for your clients—not just sell a policy.
At the same time, I see that as one of the biggest opportunities. There’s a real need for professionals who can simplify coverage, educate clients, and help them feel confident in their decisions—especially in both personal and commercial lines.
Another opportunity I see is growth. The industry is evolving, and there’s so much room to build relationships, develop your expertise, and create a long-term, meaningful career. For me, stepping into agency ownership is part of that opportunity—being able to make a bigger impact, not just for my clients, but for the people I mentor and work alongside. Ultimately, while the challenges are real, I think they’re what create the greatest opportunity to stand out and truly make a difference.
05What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?
Integrity is something I never compromise on. Whether I’m working with clients or showing up at home, it’s about doing the right thing, being honest, and being someone people can truly trust.
Consistency is another big one for me. I’ve learned that success isn’t built overnight—it’s built in the everyday moments, in showing up even when it’s hard. And that same consistency carries into my life as a partner and a parent. My family depends on me to show up for them, just like my clients do. But more than anything, relationships are what drive everything I do. My significant other and my kids are my foundation. They’re my support system, my motivation, and my reason why. Every goal I set and every step I take in my career is about building a life that creates stability, opportunity, and something meaningful for them. So when it comes down to it, the way I show up in my work is a reflection of who I am at home—committed, dependable, and focused on taking care of the people who matter most.
Join Influential Women and start making an impact. Register now.