Kimberly Foltz, MA, Insurance Executive on Influential Women
Verified Member

Influential Woman · Insurance

Kimberly Foltz, MA

Insurance Executive, Mutual Assurance Society of Virginia

Richmond, VA 23230

4Awards received

Certifications · Degrees · Memberships

Degree MA Degree Law Cert Data Analytics Certificate Cert MA, Law Cert Body Pump Certification Cert Delegation Certification Member Virginia Association of Mutual Insurance Companies (VAMIC) - Board Member Member Boy Scouts of America – Program Director Member Church Life Group Leader Member Future Business Leaders of America (FBLA) – Industry Mentor

Her Story

About Kimberly

Kimberly Foltz is an accomplished insurance executive with more than three decades of experience in underwriting, sales, marketing, and strategic operations within the property and casualty insurance industry. Her career spans a broad range of leadership roles, including underwriting management, territory leadership, and executive-level oversight across personal, commercial, farm, flood, and workers’ compensation lines. Currently serving as an executive at Mutual Assurance Society of Virginia, she leads underwriting operations while also contributing to strategic initiatives and marketing execution in a direct-to-consumer insurance environment.

Throughout her career, Kimberly has built a reputation for bridging technical underwriting expertise with strong relationship-driven sales leadership. She has held senior roles at organizations including Northern Neck Insurance Company, The Philadelphia Contributionship, and Brethren Mutual Insurance Company, where she developed deep experience in agency relations, field marketing, and operational leadership. Known for her ability to identify and remove operational bottlenecks, she focuses on translating strategic goals into actionable outcomes that improve efficiency, strengthen customer relationships, and drive organizational performance.

Kimberly holds a Master of Arts in Law from Regent University School of Law and a Data Analytics Certificate from Cornell University, further strengthening her ability to integrate regulatory understanding with data-informed decision-making. She is also actively engaged in industry and community leadership, including serving on the Board of the Virginia Association of Mutual Insurance Companies and mentoring future professionals through educational initiatives such as Future Business Leaders of America. Recognized nationally for her leadership and service, she continues to focus on innovation, mentorship, and advancing opportunities within the insurance sector while preparing for a future centered on leadership speaking and professional development advocacy.

Her Interview

Ten minutes with Kimberly

01What do you attribute your success to?

I attribute my success to resilience, perseverance, and being open to feedback throughout my career. I always say feedback's a gift, and if you're not open to it and you're closed-minded, you won't take those little nuggets and carry them forward to improve yourself. I've had some tough bosses who really looked out for me holistically, and while some people might be offended by that kind of comprehensive feedback, I wasn't. I wanted to do better. I had mentors who gave me feedback not only on specific skills but also on how I carry myself, how I present myself, and the perception others have of me. I'll never forget one boss telling me, 'when you go up to training in Connecticut, you're gonna be in a fishbowl.' He would describe things that nobody typically cared to talk about, and I appreciated that honest guidance. I've also learned to be adaptable and embrace challenges. Even after 30 years in insurance, when I can tweak things a little bit - like working with a company that has a perpetual policy versus a traditional one, or managing direct-to-consumer versus working through independent agents - I find myself challenged, and that's what I like. I believe strong mentorship, personal discipline, and maintaining a growth mindset have been instrumental in my professional development.

02What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?

The best career advice I've received came from my mentors who taught me that feedback is a gift. I had a boss at Travelers who really looked out for me holistically, and while some people might be offended by that kind of comprehensive guidance, I embraced it because I wanted to do better. He gave me feedback not only on specific skills but also on how I carry myself, how I present myself, and the perception others have of me. I'll never forget him telling me, 'when you go up to training in Connecticut, you're gonna be in a fishbowl.' He would describe things that nobody typically cared to talk about - the subtle aspects of professional presence and leadership that make a real difference. That willingness to give honest, complete feedback helped me grow not just professionally but personally as well. The lesson I took from that is to always remain open to feedback and not let a closed mind prevent you from taking those little nuggets and carrying them forward to improve yourself.

03What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?

My advice to young women entering the insurance industry or any business field is to have the resilience and the courage to go after what you want. Don't allow any fear that you might create in your own head, and any barriers, to stop you from pursuing those dreams. I also encourage young women to remain open to feedback and embrace continuous learning. Feedback is a gift, and if you're closed-minded and won't take those little nuggets and carry them forward to improve yourself, you'll miss out on tremendous growth opportunities. Be willing to step outside your comfort zones and don't be afraid to pursue leadership opportunities. Throughout my career, I've learned that growth often comes through mentorship, honest feedback, and being willing to take on challenges that might seem daunting at first. Even after 30 years in my industry, I still seek out new challenges because that's what keeps me engaged and growing.

04What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?

One of the biggest challenges in the insurance industry right now is execution - being able to take great ideas and actually get them out the door to benefit operations. I think the biggest challenge for many executives is that you can have great ideas, but if you don't know how to execute on them and get them out the door, then it doesn't do the operation any good. I'm very sensitive to identifying why things aren't moving forward, finding the bottlenecks, and then working to eliminate those bottlenecks so that strategic plans can continue to be executed. At the same time, there are tremendous opportunities for professionals who can successfully adapt and help modernize traditional business operations. In my current role, I'm working with a company that has a very different model - they have a perpetual policy rather than traditional insurance policies, and they're direct-to-consumer when I'm used to working through independent agents. Even after 30 years in the industry, when you can tweak things and work in a different model, you find yourself challenged in new ways. That kind of innovation and willingness to do things differently creates real opportunities for growth and improvement in our industry.

05What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?

The values most important to me in both my work and personal life are resilience, continuous growth, faith, service, and mentorship. I believe strongly in being open to feedback and maintaining a growth mindset - I always say feedback's a gift, and being willing to learn and improve has been essential throughout my career. Faith plays a central role in my life, as I lead a life group at my church, usually composed of women, where we do various studies in the spring and fall. I try to stay involved and active in my church community wherever I can plug myself in. Service and giving back are also core values for me. I serve on the board of the Virginia Association of Mutual Insurance Companies, and I'm particularly passionate about connecting the insurance industry with Future Business Leaders of America students to help introduce young people to opportunities in our field. I believe in helping others grow professionally while maintaining authenticity and accountability. On a personal level, I value continuous learning and self-improvement - I even set a goal to read 100 books in a year as I approach 60. I also prioritize physical fitness and staying active, whether that's through body pump classes or walking three miles every day with my lab, Bella. These values of growth, service, faith, and resilience guide both my professional decisions and my personal life.

Join Influential Women and start making an impact. Register now.