Kristi Andrews

Human Resources Consultant
Ordinary HR Consulting
Dixfield, ME 04224

Kristi Andrews is a dedicated HR professional and consultant passionate about empowering people and driving meaningful organizational change. With over fifteen years of experience in human resources and two decades of volunteer service in church ministry, she has developed a unique expertise in guiding mission-driven organizations, nonprofits, and faith-based institutions. Kristi specializes in aligning compliance with compassion, helping leaders navigate complex HR challenges while fostering cultures of trust, respect, and purpose. Her career began in public sector HR with the City of Laramie in Wyoming, where she progressed from intern to Deputy Director, overseeing the full spectrum of HR functions including policy development, employee relations, talent acquisition, and wellness initiatives. Along the way, Kristi honed her skills in leadership, risk management, and workforce planning, and played a key role in navigating organizations through challenging periods, including the COVID-19 pandemic. She has also contributed to numerous consulting projects, developing handbooks, onboarding programs, and training systems that continue to support organizations long after her direct involvement. Now based in Maine, Kristi serves clients through Ordinary HR Consulting while continuing her community and church involvement. Her work is driven by a commitment to integrity, ethical leadership, and the belief that even ordinary actions can create extraordinary impact. With a Bachelor of Applied Science in Business Administration and multiple HR and leadership certifications, she combines academic knowledge with practical experience to help organizations and their people thrive.

• Becoming a Manager Your Team Loves
• Ethics Conversations: Building an Ethics-Based Culture
• Organizational Learning and Development
• Building a People Analytics Strategy
• Professional in Human Resources (PHR)
• Strategic HR Metrics

• Laramie County Community College - BASc

Q

What do you attribute your success to?

Prayer. I spend time in prayer before I attend events, as I talk to clients, and before I offer solutions.

Q

What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?

My first HR supervisor often said "Fofo," which was her reminder to "Find out before you freak out."

Q

What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?

You need tough skin to work in HR, and an even tougher one to step into consulting. You’re often the person who speaks up when no one else will, who calls out a leader’s poor behavior, who has to let go of people you genuinely like, and who gets rejected or ignored more times than you can count. But when it goes right, you make a quiet, meaningful impact that can shift the entire direction of an organization. And that part makes every hard moment worth it.

Q

What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?

One of the biggest challenges in HR right now, especially in churches and nonprofits, is the tension between big mission and limited resources. Organizations are trying to do meaningful work in their communities, but budgets and staffing simply haven’t kept pace. As a result, they’re relying more heavily on volunteers.


That creates both opportunity and complexity. Volunteers still need clear training, consistent expectations, and appropriate oversight. There are legal considerations (particularly when paid staff also volunteer), and safety requirements like background checks, incident protocols, and, when necessary, the difficult task of asking a volunteer to step down due to harmful behavior.


AI is another emerging opportunity. It can streamline administrative tasks and free up staff time, but it also brings legal and ethical questions. And in many cases, the relational nature of ministry and nonprofit work means the human touch is still worth the extra effort.


I love helping organizations navigate this balance, protecting their mission, strengthening their people systems, and making sure their good work is sustainable.

Q

What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?

In my work life, my core values are compliance and compassion.


I start every situation by grounding myself in the facts: What federal, state, or local laws apply? What do the organization’s policies say? What precedent has been set? Once that foundation is clear, there’s room for creativity in how to solve the issue.


Compassion shapes everything that comes next. To me, compassion means seeking to understand where someone is coming from and responding with respect and care, while still upholding the standards that keep an organization healthy. Whether I’m delivering difficult news or navigating an organizational shift, I try to put myself in each person’s shoes. If a termination is necessary, I think carefully about how the individual needs to hear the message and what support or follow‑up may be needed for everyone involved. During broader changes, I consider how each person will be affected, what communication will build trust and buy‑in, and whether adjustments to supervision, pay, or classification are appropriate.


Locations

Ordinary HR Consulting

Dixfield, ME 04224

Remote