Morgan Scott, Chief Operating Officer  ​​​​​ on Influential Women
Verified Member

Influential Woman · Insurance

Morgan Scott

CIC, NCCPT-CPT

Chief Operating Officer ​​​​​, The Mahoney Group

Chandler, AZ 85224

22Years experience
1Award received

Certifications · Degrees · Memberships

Degree Arizona State University - W. P. Carey School of Business - Management Cert CIC Cert NCCPT-CPT Member Prescott Fire Charities (Board Member)
“

There's no "normal" for staying connected it's less about quantity and more about quality. Connection doesn't have to look a certain way, it just has to be intentional.

Morgan Scott · In Her Own Words

From How She Did It Explore All Topics

I promised myself to lead with the three C's: Curious. Confident. Coachable. The loudest voice isn't always the wisest.

The Hardest Promise She Ever Kept to Herself

Explore more

Her Story

About Morgan

Morgan Scott is the Chief Operating Officer and Partner at The Mahoney Group. She brings 21 years of experience in the insurance industry, 16 of which have been spent at The Mahoney Group, where she grew through service, management, training, and leadership positions on the service side of the business before stepping into her current role.

As COO, Morgan oversees enterprise operations, with particular focus on service departments, HR, claims, and the infrastructure that supports the company’s teams. Her experience in service shaped her understanding of what teams need to deliver a strong client experience. She now applies that knowledge to closing gaps between departments, challenging “we’ve always done it this way,” and helping teams turn ideas into action.

Candid and curious, Morgan believes leadership starts with knowing who you are and recognizing the value you bring before introducing your title. She encourages others to own their bold, bring their perspective to the table, and lead beyond their title. The world has enough copies.

She is known for putting people first, investing in mentorship, and having candid conversations about the everyday challenges of leadership, from challenging “we’ve always done it this way” to navigating the unwritten dress codes of the business world. She’s still on a mission to figure out what “golf attire” means for women. She brings directness, curiosity, and a sense of humor, with a goal of leaving a room better than she entered it.

She holds a Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation and is a Certified Personal Trainer through ACE Fitness. Outside of TMG, Morgan serves on the Prescott Firefighter Charities board and owns Live Well Fitness LLC with her husband, a personal training and nutrition business.

Based in the Greater Phoenix area, Morgan is passionate about helping others recognize the unique puzzle piece they bring, own who they are, and lead beyond their title. And while she may arrive a little overdressed, she believes a smile goes a long way and helping someone forward is something everyone can do.

Her Interview

Ten minutes with Morgan

01What do you attribute your success to?

I attribute my success to staying curious, candid, and coachable, and to believing that something is better than nothing. Small, intentional steps add up. I’ve grown because of people who challenged me, encouraged me, and told me the truth, and I try to do the same for others through mentorship and honest conversations.

02What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?

The best career advice I’ve received is to believe in yourself, but BE YOU. Easy to say, harder to live.

For me, it looks like showing up as all of me: heels, a jug of water, a protein shake, and usually a little overdressed. For a long time I wondered whether I looked like what a COO is “supposed” to look like. Then I realized I was the one holding that picture. Now I lean into who I am more and more, because it’s part of what I bring.

Imposter syndrome still shows up. When it does, I remind myself that I wasn’t brought to the table to be a copy of anyone. The world has enough copies. I learn from others, listen to different perspectives, and stay coachable, but I don’t let someone else’s opinion, including my own old assumptions, define who I am or what I can do.

Just as important, be the person in the room people can count on. Follow through on what you say, have the honest conversation, and be willing to help someone else along. You don’t have to have every answer, but people should know you’ll listen, take ownership, and work toward a solution. To me, that’s being the leader behind the title.

03What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?

Create your career portfolio from day one. Think of it as writing your own press release as you go. Keep a running list of your wins: the process you fixed, the client you kept, the project you led, the kind note someone sent you. You will forget more than you think, and when it’s time for a review, a promotion conversation, or a new opportunity, you’ll have the proof ready. That’s how you make the invisible visible.

Don’t wait until you feel completely ready. You can still be learning AND have something valuable to contribute. If you have an idea in the meeting, say it in the meeting, not in the hallway afterward. You won’t be everyone’s cup of tea, and that’s okay. You can listen, learn, and grow without becoming someone else to belong.

Learn the business, ask questions, and follow through. Find your truth teller, the person who will challenge you, encourage you, and tell you what you need to hear. Then be a truth teller for someone else. We all need one.

And remember that both can be true. You can be confident AND scared, strong AND human. We all have a unique puzzle piece to bring.

04What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?

Insurance is FUN, and I’ll keep saying it until more people believe me. The buzzword we all know right now is AI, and I think it’s one of the biggest opportunities our industry has. I’ve seen what happens when the right tools take on the repetitive work: people get more time for what clients actually value, like advice, relationships, and solving problems. AI won’t replace the human side of this business. It gives us room to lean into it.

The challenge is that none of us have it all figured out. I call it living in the grey. The tools change every month, and there won’t be a perfect plan. Waiting for one usually means standing still. Stay curious, try things, ask questions, and be willing to take a step while you’re still learning. You don’t have to be an expert to start.

For women, the expectations around how we should show up and lead are still real. AI is a chance to change that. A new table is being set, and the people who lean in now will help shape how this industry works for years to come. Make sure you have a seat at it, and make room for others to join you.

05What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?

My values are a lot like training: they only count if you practice them, especially when no one is watching. For me, that comes down to being real, taking ownership, and showing up for people, at work and at home.

I never want to forget the “people” behind people. We’ve all had a hospital moment, or we will: the phone call, the waiting room, the day when work suddenly doesn’t matter at all. The person across from you in a meeting might be in one right now, and you may never know. That should shape how we listen and how we hold each other accountable. Caring about someone and being honest with them aren’t opposites. Most of the time, the honest conversation is the caring one.

Growth matters to me too, and it works just like training. You don’t get stronger lifting what’s easy. You have to put yourself in uncomfortable positions until they feel comfortable, and then do it again. That includes owning my mistakes out loud, not just quietly fixing them. And I’ve learned that the difference we make usually isn’t the big decision. It’s asking one more question or checking in. That’s how you leave a room better than you found it.

Ohh, and smile. It goes a long way.

Join Influential Women and start making an impact. Register now.