Natalie S. Williams
Natalie S. Williams is a distinguished attorney, adjunct professor, and author based in Griffith, Indiana. As the founder of NSW Legal, LLC, she specializes in criminal defense and family law, providing strategic, client-focused representation that empowers individuals navigating complex legal challenges. Known for her unwavering commitment to integrity, fairness, and excellence, Natalie has built a reputation for thoughtful advocacy and personalized legal solutions. Her leadership at NSW Legal emphasizes both the legal and human aspects of practice, ensuring clients receive guidance that is both knowledgeable and compassionate.
Natalie’s passion for criminal law stems from over 13 years in law enforcement, while family law comprises about 20% of her practice, including cases involving domestic violence and custody disputes. Having personally navigated divorce and custody proceedings, she brings a rare depth of empathy and understanding to her clients’ experiences. Her approach is pragmatic and strategic—rooted in her belief that the best defense against challenges, whether in the courtroom or in life, is a well-planned, deliberate offense. Natalie’s prior roles as a Deputy Prosecuting Attorney and as an attorney at Blankenship Law, LLC, equipped her with a broad perspective on the law, strengthening her skills in litigation, jury selection, and client advocacy.
A committed educator and mentor, Natalie serves as an Adjunct Professor at the Indiana Institute of Technology, inspiring future legal professionals through her teaching and guidance. Her daily routine reflects her dedication to both her profession and family: rising at 4 AM to prepare spiritually and mentally for the day, she balances court appearances, client consultations, and jail visits with parenting duties, ensuring her son receives support and care. Evening hours are often spent returning to attorney mode, drafting motions, and strategizing for her clients. Guided by her motto, “greatness is a choice,” Natalie embraces each day with focus, resilience, and purpose, knowing that her work can profoundly impact the lives of others.
• Indiana Supreme Court Bar Admission (2016)
• US District Court for the Northern District of Indiana
• US District Court for the Southern District of Indiana
• United States Supreme Court Bar Admission
• Valparaiso University - JD
• Valparaiso University - MA, Psychology
• North Carolina Central University - BS, Criminal Justice and Corrections
• 2025 Phenomnal WIN (Women of Impact) Award
• James C. Kimbrough Bar Association
• National Bar Association
• Gary Cougars Pop Warner Organization (Board Member
• Academic Advisor
• Legal Counsel)
• Cyber Bros (President of the Board)
• Sigma Gamma Rho Sorority Incorporated
• Tau Beta Sigma National Honorary Band Sorority Incorporated
• Phi Alpha Delta Law Fraternity, International
• Cyber Bros - Nonprofit teaching kids about cyberbullying
• Gary Cougars Pop Warner Organization - Academic advisor and legal counsel
What do you attribute your success to?
I attribute my success to choosing greatness every single day. My motto is 'greatness is a choice,' and I wake up every day choosing to be great because someone's life is in my hands. When I'm working on a criminal case, their constitutional rights are in my hands. When I'm working on a family law case, their children and divorce proceedings are in my hands. They're looking to me for guidance and support, so I have to be great every day. At that point during this time at work, it's not about me - it's about them. I live off very little sleep because my brain wakes up at 4 AM, sometimes even 3 AM, mentally preparing and drafting motions. I've been known to file things at 5 in the morning because I can't sleep when I have important work to do. I studied 10 to 12 hours a day, 6 days a week for 3 months to pass the bar on my first try because as a single mom with a 3-year-old son, I didn't have the opportunity to take it again. He needed his mom, and I didn't want to raise a latchkey kid. That same dedication and hard work that got me through law school is what drives me every single day in my practice.
What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?
The best career advice I ever received was from my own divorce lawyer during my divorce proceedings. I was very upset one day because my ex-husband was lying in court and trying to destroy my reputation as an attorney. I was in the hallway going off about it, and she grabbed me by my hand, pulled me into a conference room, and said, 'Suck it up, buttercup. I need you to get it together. You are an attorney. You are always an attorney.' That snapped me back into reality. I've taken that advice and made it my own approach with my clients. Suck it up, buttercup - we don't have time to cry, we don't have time to be petty, we don't have time for tit for tat. The best defense when you're dealing with a narcissistic spouse and you're trying to get out is an effective, planned offense. We cannot be reactive, we have to be proactive. That moment taught me to stay professional no matter what, and it's advice I now pass on to my own clients who are going through difficult situations.
What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?
My advice to young women entering law is to first know why you want to be a lawyer. I went to law school with people who honestly said they were just there because they didn't know what else to do - that is the wrong mindset to have. Know why you want to be a lawyer. Find your passion within the law that ignites you. Be authentically you. There are a whole bunch of attorneys walking around, and you see those put-together pretty boxes in commercials, but be authentically you. No one can defend or represent clients better than you can when you're being yourself. Just because there are a plethora of attorneys in this world doesn't mean you cannot do an effective job and make a difference. Think about it like doctors - there might be 105,000 doctors that do the same thing in your county, but they all have a full patient list. Why? Because every doctor isn't for everybody, even though they do the same thing. So trust your gut, know what you're getting into, and never let anybody tell you different. If they tell you you can't make it through, you don't need them - move on. Don't let them tell you you can't do it. You can, you will, and you do.
What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?
Justice has always been my passion, and one of the greatest challenges in my field is ensuring that every individual has access to fair and equitable representation, particularly in criminal defense and family law. Many clients do not fully understand their rights or how to navigate the legal system, and I see this as an opportunity to educate, empower, and advocate with both strategy and compassion. Balancing the demands of legal practice with personal responsibilities, especially as a single parent, has taught me the value of discipline, resilience, and careful planning qualities I bring to every case. For me, each matter is more than just a legal issue; it is a chance to protect freedoms, restore balance, and positively impact the lives of those I serve, guided by my principle that “greatness is a choice.”
What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?
My top three values are honesty, integrity, and zealous advocacy. I cannot lie to my client - I'm not that person. I tell them straight up: if you want an attorney that's going to feed you wolf tickets and tell you stories with rose-colored glasses, then I am not the one. You need to find somebody else. I am a straight, no chaser shooter, because I feel like that's the best way to be so there are no misunderstandings as to what's going on and what is being expected of them. Life is happening, and they cannot afford to be living in a fantasy. My friends will tell you, if you don't want to know the truth, do not ask Natalie, because she will share her feelings. But she'll do it in a loving way. I've had lawyers tell me that I hurt their feelings, but they knew it was in a loving way because things had to be done. I can't defend what I don't know, and that goes for criminal cases and family law cases. I can't possibly assist you if I don't know the truth. So not only am I always honest with my clients, I demand that they be honest with me, because I can't do my job if they're not. It affects them just as much as me. I'm also a die-hard, zealous advocate. I'm going to fight for you. If justice needs to be done, I'm going to fight for you. Even if you were rightfully accused, do you deserve to spend the rest of your life in jail? Let's find a happy medium that the state can be happy with, that the victim can be happy with, that you can be happy with. There are very few horrible people, very few Jeffrey Dahmers walking around. Most people just make dumb decisions, and you shouldn't have to spend the rest of your life making up for one dumb decision if you don't have to.