Member Voices

Beyond Punishment: A Tenth Grader’s Powerful Voice on Justice, Accountability and Rehabilitation

Balancing Accountability and Development: An Ethical Examination of California's Juvenile Justice System

By Annabelle Dalmacy “Each of us is more than the worst thing we’ve ever done.” Attorney Bryan Stevenson challenges the notion that an individual’s worst actions should define their future. When a minor commits a felony in California, California’s juvenile justice system faces a dilemma between retribution and rehabilitation.

1 Under California law, minors accused of certain felonies may be transferred from juvenile court to adult criminal court following a judicial hearing.

2 Developmental differences in minors complicate the question of how they should be held accountable for felonies. Many individuals debate whether minors should face the same or different consequences as adults while regarding differences in psychological ability.

Balancing these competing moral obligations is essential to determining justice for juveniles. It is important to uphold ethics in the justice system to ensure justice for victims and fair treatment for juveniles. Therefore, the aforementioned must be evaluated through an ethical lens to assess the question:

To what extent should California’s juvenile justice system hold minors criminally responsible for felonies? Moral Responsibility Regarding Minors Some individuals may argue that holding minors to the same level of criminal responsibility as adults is unfair because minors have not yet reached the same level of psychological and emotional maturity.

Juvenile justice advocates and psychologists often support this perspective because they believe juveniles should be held accountable in ways that recognize their developmental differences. In a scholarly article written by Laurence Steinberg, a professor of psychology specializing in adolescent psychological development, and Elizabeth S. Scott, a professor of law at Columbia Law School and leading voice of juvenile justice, both argue that juveniles should not be held to the same standards of criminal responsibility as adults.

3. Both authors support this statement because since minors’ decision-making abilities are developing, they are less able to resist coercive influence.

Therefore, it is seen as unethical to harshly punish minors who do not fully understand the nature of their crimes. Similarly, Caitlin Cavanagh, an associate professor at Michigan State University School of Criminal Justice, emphasizes that minors are developmentally distinct from adults, supporting the need for responses tailored to the fact that minors do not have the same maturity as adults.

4. Together, these sources suggest that assigning minors the same level of criminal responsibility as adults may disregard important developmental differences. From an ethical standpoint, justice should consider not only the severity of an offense but also the juvenile’s capacity for mature decision making. Ultimately, California’s juvenile justice system must balance accountability with fairness by considering minors’ developmental maturity when determining the extent of their criminal responsibility. Opposingly, some victims and their families argue that holding minors criminally responsible for serious felonies can be justified because individuals have a moral obligation to be accountable for the harm their actions cause. Barry C. Feld, a legal scholar and professor at the University of Minnesota Law School, examines the relationship between youth focused policies and crime policy objectives, emphasizing that the juvenile justice system involves a balance between protecting and developing young people while also protecting society from crime.

5. This demonstrates how there has to be a balance between keeping society safe by enforcing consequences for crimes while simultaneously reinforcing good morale for juveniles. This perspective is also supported by an empirical study conducted by Charles E. Loeffler, an associate professor of criminology at the University of Pennsylvania, and Ben Grunwald, a professor at the Duke University School of Law.

Their research found that processing juveniles as adults reduced the probability of recidivism, the act of continuing to commit crimes even after punishment, by three to five percent in the population studied. 7 This suggests that adult prosecution may have a deterrent effect under certain circumstances, however, this finding does not prove adult processing as the best course of action for every minor who commits a felony. Naturally, justice must account for both the rights of victims and the responsibility to protect society, while also considering whether the punishment is proportionate to the offense and the minor’s maturity. Punishment Versus Rehabilitation Some youth advocates and juvenile defense attorneys believe that it is more ethical to prioritize rehabilitation over adult punishment for minors.

In an additional work published by Barry C. Feld, he contends that modern juvenile courts prioritize disciplinary punishment over providing the rehabilitative support and care that minors actually require.

6 Specifically, Feld argues that the juvenile court system has gradually shifted away from its original foundational mission: addressing the underlying social, developmental, and psychological needs of minors. Analogously, Richard E. Redding, a professor at Chapman University Dale E. Fowler School of Law with expertise in juvenile justice and psychology, establishes that prosecuting and imprisoning juveniles as adults yields virtually no benefits while creating severe, long term risks.

7 This illustrates that not only do juveniles not benefit from this, but society as well. Redding’s findings suggest that adult-style punishment may not be the most justified response to juvenile crime, particularly because it can actively undermine personal rehabilitation and future reintegration into society. This can be unethical if this causes juveniles to consequently suffer from negative effects on their life.

Together, both Feld and Redding demonstrate that modern courts increasingly penalize minors’ offenses rather than addressing their actual needs. Adversely, some victims, public safety advocates, and prosecutors believe that it can be ethically justified to use stronger punishment when it protects society and provides accountability for felonies committed by minors. David L. Meyers, who holds a Ph.D in Criminology and Criminal Justice and is a professor at the University of New Haven, argues that the practice of sending juveniles to adult court should be reserved for the most serious juvenile offenders when extended confinement is of the utmost importance to protect society.

8 He recognizes that stronger consequences may be justified in order to prioritize public safety and accountability. It is vital for one to keep in mind that Meyers supports limiting adult-court treatment to exceptionally serious cases, not every minor who commits a felony. This demonstrates how Myers tries to ensure the justice system operates ethically as well as fairly. Therefore, it can be plausible to say that some crimes need harsher consequences in order to keep society safe.

Subsequently, Jeffrey Fagan, a professor of law at Columbia Law School with expertise in juvenile crime, Aaron Kupchik, a professor of sociology and criminal justice at the University of Delaware with a Ph.D in Sociology, and Akiva Liberman, a health science administrator, contend that transferring only the juveniles who commit the most serious crimes to adult court can ensure that the punishment appropriately reflects the severity of their offenses when the juvenile justice system’s penalties are insufficient.9 Their scholarly findings impose that stronger consequences on certain minors can be justified when their crimes are exceptionally serious and require greater accountability.

Therefore, it can be appropriate in specific cases of serious crimes committed by minors to warrant a transfer to adult court when juvenile court penalties are insufficient to provide punishment proportionate to the severity of their offenses. Conclusion Ergo, the extent to which California’s juvenile justice system should hold minors responsible for felonies depends on the severity of the offense, the minor’s maturity, and the need to protect society.

From an ethical standpoint, justice requires balancing the responsibility to hold juvenile offenders accountable while also recognizing the fact that minors are still developing and possess the capacity for change. It can be argued that California should adopt an individualized approach as well as consider the best interests of the juvenile offenders and the public as a whole when determining an ethically viable solution to this matter.

Notes 1. “Definition of Minor.” California Code, Family Code - FAM § 6500 2. California Welfare and Institutions Code § 707 3. Laurence Steinberg and Elizabeth S. Scott, “Less Guilty by Reason of Adolescence: Developmental Immaturity, Diminished Responsibility, and the Juvenile Death Penalty.” American Psychologist, vol. 58, no. 12, 2003 4. Caitlin Cavanagh, “Healthy Adolescent Development and the Juvenile Justice System: Challenges and Solutions.” Child Development Perspectives, vol. 16, no. 3, 2022, pp. 141–147. 5. Barry C. Feld, The Evolution of the Juvenile Court: Race, Politics, and the Criminalizing of Juvenile Justice. New York University Press, 2017. 6. Barry C. Feld, “Criminalizing the American Juvenile Court.” Crime and Justice, vol. 17, 1993, pp. 197-280. 7. Richard E. Redding, “The Effects of Adjudicating and Sentencing Juveniles as Adults: Research and Policy Implications.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, vol. 1, no. 2, 2003, pp. 128-155 8. David L. Myers, “Juvenile Transfer to Adult Court: Ongoing Search for Scientific Support.” Criminology & Public Policy, vol. 15, no. 3, 2016, pp. 927–938. 9. Jeffrey Fagan, Aaron Kupchik, and Akiva Liberman, 2004. “Be Careful What You Wish for: The Comparative Impacts of Juvenile Versus Criminal Court Sanctions on Recidivism Among Adolescent Felony Offenders.” SSRN Electronic Journal, ahead of print. Bibliography Cal. Legislature. 2025. “California Welfare and Institutions Code Section 707.01 (2025).” California.Public.Law.

https://california.public.law/codes/welfare_and_institutions_code_section_707.01. Cavanagh, Caitlin. 2022. “Healthy Adolescent Development and the Juvenile Justice System: Challenges and Solutions.” Child Development Perspectives 16 (3): 141–47. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdep.12461. Fagan, Jeffrey, Aaron Kupchik, and Akiva Liberman. 2004. “Be Careful What You Wish for: The Comparative Impacts of Juvenile Versus Criminal Court Sanctions on Recidivism Among Adolescent Felony Offenders.” SSRN Electronic Journal, ahead of print. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.491202. Feld, Barry C. 1993. “Criminalizing the American Juvenile Court.” Crime and Justice 17 (January): 197–280. https://doi.org/10.1086/449214. Feld, Barry C. 2017. The Evolution of the Juvenile Court. September 19. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt1pwtbmh. FindLaw. 2025. “California Code, Family Code - FAM § 6500 | FindLaw.” https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/family-code/fam-sect-6500/. Myers, David L. 2016. “Juvenile Transfer to Adult Court.” Criminology & Public Policy 15 (3): 927–38. https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9133.12232. Redding, Richard E. 2003. “The Effects of Adjudicating and Sentencing Juveniles as Adults.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice 1 (2): 128–55. https://doi.org/10.1177/1541204002250875. Steinberg, Laurence. 2008. “A Social Neuroscience Perspective on Adolescent Risk-Taking.” Developmental Review 28 (1): 78–106. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dr.2007.08.002. Steinberg, Laurence, and Elizabeth S Scott. 2003. “Less Guilty by Reason of Adolescence: Developmental Immaturity, Diminished Responsibility, and the Juvenile Death Penalty.” The American Psychologist 58 (12): 1009–18. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.58.12.1009.

A Note on the Original Publication;

The research paper that is reproduced in its original form, without editing, rewriting, or modification to the author's arguments, language, structure, citations, or conclusions. It is presented as Annabelle's independent academic contribution, with full acknowledgement of her authorship.

My intention is not to reinterpret her work, but to provide a platform through which her own research, analysis, and developing academic voice may be appreciated. She was inducted in the National Junior Honors Society the moment she became eligible, from the 6th grade. One of the top students in every subject from nursery until now. Anabelle recently completed a 10-day course in advanced medicine at Georgetown University earning two college credits in the process.

For the Summer, she will do a short course in Dermatology at Columbia University.

She’s currently been recruited by colleges, like John Hopkins, the University of Chicago, among others.

As we advance the message of “Her Rights. Her Voice. Her Justice,” may we also remember that empowering the next generation begins with recognising their capacity to think, question, research, and participate in the pursuit of a more just society.

Share
About the Author Dr. Onika Campbell-Rowe Global Chief Human Rights & Humanitarian Officer - Envoy to the United Nations, Implementation Universal Declaration of Human Rights / World Diplomatic Organisation/ Canadian International Chaplaincy Association ECOSOC

I am Her Excellency Ambassador Dr. Onika Campbell-Rowe, PhD, an international diplomat, humanitarian leader, human rights advocate, academic, investigative journalist, and development practitioner with more than two decades of experience serving governments, international organizations, civil society, and vulnerable communities across the Caribbean, Africa, Europe, and North America. My life's work is dedicated to…

Share your perspective

Publish your story on Influential Women

Become a Contributor