Member Voices

Defining Liberty

Exploring the Philosophical and Constitutional Foundations of Liberty as a Social Contract

"On MacCallum's analysis, then, there is no simple dichotomy between positive and negative liberty; rather, we should recognize that there is a whole range of possible interpretations or conceptions of the single concept of liberty.[\[1\]]

An inquiry into the origin of 'liberty'

must first consider the origin of common law. If liberty is neither a natural right nor freedom, and is thus bound by the constraints of natural freedoms, one must consider the origins of common law in establishing boundaries around the concept of 'liberty'. Magna Carta: Muse and Mentor\[2\] explores the cost of "liberty" and the manifestation of common law through the development of lawful due process and its implications for inalienable rights against oppression. The United States Constitution can be directly derived from the agreement at Runnymede in 1215.

Liberty is a social contract established between agents of natural-born civilian rights and their governing establishment through an exchange of regulated freedoms that provide for the common good.[\[3\]]

There is a differing perspective on the application of governance

in defining the boundaries of liberty and determining who may obtain this entitlement under modern versus foundational United States constitutional doctrine. In the Founding Fathers' initial conception of civil liberty, particularly regarding the original construction of the Bill of Rights, the amendments were preliminary to Article V. Liberty, regardless of its doctrine under supreme law, was bound by federal jurisdiction and did not extend to state obligations until the establishment of the 14th Amendment in 1868.

This led to the constitutional obligation to incorporate the first ten amendments through the 14th Amendment, extending their protections to state and local governance as inalienable rights. Thus, this idea of "liberty for all" was not established for anyone outside the federation, nor did it include women, enslaved persons, vagrants, or those who did not or could not own property. Civil liberty was reserved for wealthy white men in federal political positions of power.

Through Supreme Court determinations, the door to incorporating federal protections has been opened to local and state governance. However, this incorporation has spanned more than 150 years since the adoption of the Bill of Rights at the Constitutional Convention.\[4\] Through the 13th Amendment, enslaved people and African American citizens were granted liberties, but it wasn't until the 15th Amendment was enacted in 1870 that additional constitutional protections were established.

I personally hold a case file that would incorporate both the Fifth Amendment's Grand Jury Clause and the Seventh Amendment's Jury Trial Clause in a Supreme Court determination, with an implication dating to December 2021. It became the leading catalyst for my return to academic achievement. I have personally experienced the oppression inflicted by impoverishment in modern-day United States, and I was stripped of all constitutional liberties through court doctrine and across two governors' offices over petty and erroneous charges. This notion of liberty is not an established construct, regardless of its historical implications. This case is being prepared for filing with the federal Supreme Court through a First Amendment petition.

Some of the personal rights safeguarded by the first eight amendments against national action may also be safeguarded against state action, because a denial of them would be a denial of due process of law.

Justice Moody (Twining v. New Jersey, 1908)

The inquiry into limitations

is derived from the implications of this theory: positive, negative, and triadic formulations. Liberty, or freedom, should be limited when the infringement of one person's liberty causes the removal of another person's liberty, or when the moral or intentional responsibility for one agent's actions can be attributed to the removal of another agent's ability to act.

… One possibility is the causal view, according to which I am unfree to do something whenever my inabilities are casually attributed to another person's action… Another possibility is the moral responsibility view, according to which we must ask whether the agent who created the obstacle can be held morally responsible for my inability… The latter view makes freedom partly dependent on moral judgments, whereas the former treats freedom as an empirical behavioral concept, requiring only knowledge of causal relations, and therefore allows persons with different moral judgements to agree on whether someone is unfree. It had recently been suggested that if moral responsibility is understood broadly, as moral answerability, the two views may converge, since the set of actions for which agents are answerable is arguably coextensive with the set of actions that generate unfreedom under the causality view. On this capacious account, agents can, in principle, be asked to answer for any obstacle their actions causally bring about, where answerability does not entail any specific moral response such as blame or praise (Huseynli 2026).[\[5\]]

\[1\] Ian Carter, "Positive and Negative Liberty," in The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. Edward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman (Stanford, CA: Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University), accessed August 31, 2026, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberty-positive-negative/.

\[2\] Holland, Randy J., ed. Magna Carta: Muse & Mentor. Washington, DC: Library of Congress, 2014.

\[3\] McGovern, Rachael. "Defining Liberty," Lecture #1, POLS4680 Constitutional Liberties, University of Idaho Online, September 6, 2026.

\[4\] McGovern, Rachael. "Defining Liberty," Lecture #3, POLS4680 Constitutional Liberties, University of Idaho Online, September 6, 2026.

\[5\] Ian Carter, "Positive and Negative Liberty," in The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. Edward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman (Stanford, CA: Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University), accessed August 31, 2026, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberty-positive-negative/.

Share
About the Author Taunie Jade Sparkes Chief Executive Officer, Mobile Systems Integration, MSI INC

Taunie Sparkes is an art gallery and distribution professional who founded sparksink.com in 2018 and specializes in literature, art, and photography. She holds a History degree with a business minor from the University of Idaho and is pursuing an MBA. Sparkes serves as a Girl Scouts troop leader and volunteers regularly in her daughter's classroom. Her daughter has been instrumental in her entrepreneurial journey…

Share your perspective

Publish your story on Influential Women

Become a Contributor