Member Voices

SAVE America Act 2025

Privacy Rights and Mass Surveillance Under the SAVE Act 2025: A Constitutional Analysis of Voter Registration Implications

There is a blanket provision within the SAVE Act 2025 that is exclusionary in its language. The majority of this provisional statement denotes amendments to specific verbiage concerning the clarity of voting rights, as they pertain to voter integrity and the rights of natural citizens to participate in provisional elections. The complexity driving this argument is the enactment of Homeland Security provisions and the manner in which domestic espionage is inflicted upon United States citizens under the political voter registry.

The prompt requests a reflection on whose liberty is at stake. I can assume there are plenty of predictable interpretations. I have to argue that it is the liberty of privacy for all United States citizens who register for federal election voting rights. The implication of the Act excludes state elections, placing an overbearing emphasis on presidential elections.

The issue with this understanding, which is mostly ineptly understood by the average United States citizen, excluding scholars, is the manner in which federal (presidential) elections are conducted, making a popular vote nearly irrelevant. In the Electoral College for federal presidential elections, the popular vote is counted; however, it does not elect a sitting president. It is a façade, so to speak, as the electoral vote is cast and thus determines the presidential election.

The electoral vote is cast by electors, who may represent the populace. However, this Act does nothing to "protect voting rights from fraud" in state and local jurisdictions. So why does this bill hold deep-seated importance within the Republican Party?

The answer, by my analysis, lies within page 15, line 5, through page 18, line 2. This provision outlines the federal demand for state offices to engage in civil espionage and mass surveillance of every registered American voter. This provision grants access to unprecedented investigations of registered voters, without probable cause or due process protections for search and seizure.

The Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act shares its exact acronym with the program detailed in its provisions: the Homeland Security Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) program, described on page 15, lines 17–22.

"(B) Use of SAVE system- The Secretary of Homeland Security may respond to a request received under paragraph (1) by using the system for the verification of immigration status under the applicable provisions of section 1137 of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 1320b-7), as established pursuant to section 121(c) of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (Public Law 99-603).
(C) Sharing of Information. - The heads of Federal departments and agencies shall share information with respect to an individual who is the subject of a request received under paragraph (A) to enable them to respond to the request."
TAUNIE JADE SPARKES POLS4680 University of Idaho, Professor Rachel McGovern Week 12 11/15/2026
2 | P a g e

Within the antagonistic morale of the United States Federal Government, I cannot fathom the implications this Act would have for all registered American voters. It openly promotes and implicates identical acronyms for a provision within voter registration, with unregulated compliance involving mass surveillance and privacy concerns. This Act could be utilized to investigate all registered U.S. voters for any reason deemed fit and applicable, regardless of the outcome of their citizenship verification. This information could be utilized for tyrannical espionage against all persons registered to exercise their natural voting rights.

The foundational significance of voting rights is governance "by the people, for the people." This is the theology upon which democracy was founded, dating back to its earliest origins within the Roman Empire. The problem with this historical application is that it has proven destructive and has crumbled within a few centuries of application. The idea of democracy is utopian; however, this "utopia" can be easily argued through communism (Marxism), socialism, etc.

Historically speaking, the right to democratic governance is bound to violate its own rights and liberties, resulting in an absolutist, tyrannical oligarchy or autocracy. The fundamental right to vote is balanced by the liberty one holds to privacy. The argument is grounded in voter suppression and casts light on individuals who may not have birth certificates from non-hospital-implicated births.

This argument does not reflect state electoral voting, and state elections are not subject to the Homeland Security Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) program. If the United States' democratic, natural, and unalienable liberty to vote is to be upheld, the congressional allocation of the Electoral College would have to be amended, or this implication of citizenship verification would have to be allocated to state and local elections. Otherwise, it is unprecedented language designed for the utility of domestic espionage and mass surveillance, coated in "voter verification." Civil rights and natural liberties, including voting rights without exclusion of those listed therein, would have to be upheld for their practice to be of significance.

[1] Roy, Chip. H.R. 22, Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act. 119th Cong., 1st sess. Introduced January 3, 2025. https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/22.

Share
About the Author Taunie Jade Sparkes Chief Executive Officer, Mobile Systems Integration, MSI INC

Taunie Sparkes is an art gallery and distribution professional who founded sparksink.com in 2018 and specializes in literature, art, and photography. She holds a History degree with a business minor from the University of Idaho and is pursuing an MBA. Sparkes serves as a Girl Scouts troop leader and volunteers regularly in her daughter's classroom. Her daughter has been instrumental in her entrepreneurial journey…

Share your perspective

Publish your story on Influential Women

Become a Contributor