Brittany Jo Tolle, Personal Injury Case Manager on Influential Women
Verified Member

Influential Woman · Legal Services (Personal Injury Law)

Brittany Jo Tolle

Personal Injury Case Manager, Schuerger Shunnarah Trial Attorneys

Martinsville, OH 45146

5Years experience

Her Story

About Brittany

Brittany Tolle is a Personal Injury Case Manager at Schuerger Shunnarah Trial Attorneys, where she helps clients navigate the legal and administrative complexities of personal injury claims. She manages a high-volume caseload involving motor vehicle accidents, commercial vehicle accidents, and the occasional premises liability case. Her responsibilities include maintaining client communication, gathering medical records and police reports, coordinating with insurance companies, preparing settlement documentation, and assisting attorneys throughout the negotiation process. With a strong background in customer service and case management, Brittany brings attention to detail, problem-solving skills, and compassion to her work. She has also completed continuing legal education through an Overview of Personal Injury Law for Paralegals course. Throughout her career, Brittany has developed extensive experience in client relations, administrative support, and navigating complex procedures. Before focusing on personal injury law, she worked in loan rehabilitation services, unemployment assistance, and facilities administration. These roles strengthened her ability to communicate effectively, manage sensitive information, maintain accurate records, and support individuals facing challenging circumstances. Brittany believes that professional and personal growth never stop, embracing change as an opportunity to gain knowledge and develop new perspectives. She values moral integrity and compassion, striving to ensure that clients feel supported and informed throughout their legal journeys. Beyond her professional responsibilities, Brittany is devoted to her family and serves as the primary caregiver and power of attorney for her elderly paternal grandmother. Her personal experiences have shaped her perspective on resilience, responsibility, and the importance of caring for others. She encourages young women entering the legal support field to speak up, build confidence, and advocate for their clients, even when doing so requires difficult conversations. Outside of work, Brittany enjoys adult coloring books, reading, writing, spending time with animals, and reading the Bible. Through her commitment to client advocacy, continuous learning, and compassionate service, she strives to make a meaningful difference in the lives of those she serves.

Her Interview

Ten minutes with Brittany

01What do you attribute your success to?

I attribute a lot of my confidence to my husband who has really helped in my confidence since I did grow up with a single parent that passed when I was 15. Moving out of my hometown after high school helped me gain more knowledge and social experience.

02What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?

Brittany's own career journey reflects the value of learning through experience, remaining open to new responsibilities, and developing confidence by navigating unfamiliar situations. Her professional background spans government-related customer service and personal injury case management, demonstrating her ability to adapt to different environments. She also emphasizes the importance of being willing to speak up and make difficult calls when the situation requires it.

03What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?

Don't be shy. Be willing to speak your mind. Be willing to make that phone call, even if it's gonna be tough. You'll get through it.

04What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?

There's a lot of personal injury firms out there. You learn something new just about every day. You get to hear a lot of people's stories and connect.

05What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?

I value strong moral principles and compassion in both my professional and personal life. I believe in treating others with kindness, understanding, and respect while maintaining integrity in everything I do.

Join Influential Women and start making an impact. Register now.