Jenna L. Hayes, SIU Investigator on Influential Women

Influential Woman · Insurance SIU Fraud Investigation

Jenna L. Hayes

SIU Investigator, Allied Universal

Kcmo, MO

Certifications · Degrees · Memberships

Degree Criminal Justice Administration degree from Northwest Missouri State and University of Phoenix Degree 2007 Cert NICTA Certifications

Her Story

About Jenna

I have been working in the insurance and investigations industry for 26 years, starting with Farmers Insurance where I spent 22 years in various roles including regulatory compliance, quality assurance, and catastrophe storm work as a field adjuster. During my time with Farmers, I lived in 6 different states, moving for the right positions. Since November 2022, I have been working as a fraud investigator with Allied Universal Compliance and Investigations, the largest investigations firm in America. I am part of a specialized team of 3 that manages our own files for particular clients. My cases range from slip and fall commercial liability losses to workers' compensation claims and motor vehicle accidents for clients like Home Depot and DoorDash. I investigate potential fraud through surveillance, medical canvas, and background checks. One of my most notable achievements was working the California wildfires as a Farmers adjuster, particularly the 2018 campfire where I was able to provide immediate assistance to families who had lost everything. I remember one man who was living in his car with his family, and I was able to get them set up with a hotel, put money in their account for clothes and necessities, because they had left with only the clothes on their backs. Over the years, I have mentored quite a few people who still save my phone number for follow-up calls and hypothetical questions, which makes me feel good that I am still a source of information for them.

Her Interview

Ten minutes with Jenna

01What do you attribute your success to?

I attribute my success to always having to work hard. My dad died when I was 11, and my mom when I was 27, so nothing's ever been given to me. I was a later-in-life kid, and my parents worked hard to raise the two of us girls. Seeing that, I knew I couldn't be a slouch or a lazy person. I needed to know the importance of responsibility and accountability, because if you don't have that, then you're not set for life as an adult. My parents' example taught me that hard work is essential, and that foundation has carried me through my entire career.

02What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?

In the insurance industry, which is very much male-driven, especially in the roles I've been in, the best advice I received was to put myself above others through education. I took a lot of extra courses through NICTA to learn strategy, how to repair items, how things break, and storm-related cause and effect. All of that helped me be the adjuster and claim representative that I was. I know this sounds cheesy and corny, but knowledge is power. I'm 5'3, and I'm not intimidating to anybody just from my appearance, but what you know matters. Roofing contractors would get on claims, and as soon as they knew certain adjusters were on those claims, they would back off or they would know what they could get away with and what they couldn't. Education and knowledge gave me that power.

03What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?

The insurance industry and the investigative industry are extremely rewarding, but you gotta stick with it. Know your worth and what you can bring to the table. Prepare yourself and learn as much as you can about the trade to make yourself successful. Being a self-starter and taking those steps will open so many doors for you. Education and preparation are key to succeeding in this field, especially as a woman in a male-driven industry.

04What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?

Fraud is alive and well. There are so many cases of fraud, and cyber security is a major concern. Scammers have evolved from robocalls and emails to text messages now. They do phishing attempts, like claiming you have an unpaid toll in a certain state, and they try to scare you with tactics about wage garnishment or fines and imprisonment. The dark web and the dark side of the community are always finding new ways to target people. There are always new methods they're trying, so it's important to keep on your toes, educate yourself, be mindful, and share that knowledge with your loved ones so they don't fall victim to it. Even with traffic lights and vehicle location recording technology, there's no anonymity in this world anymore. We can track vehicles through their VIN or license plate and see where they've been, where they regularly park, even if they've been on a highway or parked in front of a subway sandwich shop. This technology helps us investigate fraud, but it also shows how much data is being collected on everyone.

05What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?

Consistency is most important to me, as far as putting out a consistent product and knowing that my work product is a reflection of professionalism and my integrity in this industry. You're only as good as the reports and the work product that you put out there. I've been doing this for 26 years, and I've mentored quite a few people over the years. They still save my phone number for follow-up calls, what-ifs, and hypotheticals, and that makes me feel good that I'm still a source of information for quite a few people. Knowing that I've touched lives along the way is important to me.

Join Influential Women and start making an impact. Register now.