Her Story
About Kelly
Kelly Bodner is the owner and operator of Pickle on Penn, an innovative indoor pickleball facility in Carmel, Indiana. After nearly a decade of playing pickleball and organizing leagues during the COVID-19 pandemic, she recognized the need for a dedicated indoor venue that could provide year-round recreation in Indiana’s four-season climate. She brought that vision to life by navigating zoning challenges, securing community support, overseeing the design and development process, and opening the 30,000-square-foot facility in August 2024.
Under Kelly’s leadership, Pickle on Penn has established a country-club-style approach to pickleball, featuring eight cushioned indoor courts, a restaurant and bar overlooking the courts, locker rooms, air conditioning, garage-door ventilation, and a variety of programming including lessons, leagues, classes, camps, showcases, and open play. Beyond the facilities themselves, Kelly places strong emphasis on creating a welcoming community and building genuine relationships among members. Her approach includes connecting players into consistent groups and creating social experiences that encourage people to return not only for the sport, but also for the sense of belonging.
Kelly’s leadership is also shaped by her extensive involvement in nonprofit and community organizations. She has served as president of women’s guilds, co-founded the American Cancer Society Guild in Indianapolis, and co-founded the Professional Owners Forum of Indiana (POFI). She also established the Indiana Pickleball League to help connect facility owners and strengthen the sport throughout the region. Through Pickle on Penn and her broader community involvement, Kelly continues to combine entrepreneurship, hospitality, and relationship-building to create meaningful recreational experiences and strengthen the pickleball community.
Her Interview
Ten minutes with Kelly
01What do you attribute your success to?
I attribute my success to perseverance, adaptability, and building strong personal relationships. Founding and operating Pickle & Pen has taught me to navigate challenges such as zoning and creating a unique indoor facility while staying focused on building a welcoming community. I believe genuine relationships and a commitment to serving others have been key to my success.
02What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?
The best career advice I’ve received is to keep persevering. Challenges and setbacks are part of the journey, but staying committed, resilient, and focused on my goals has helped me continue moving forward.
03What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?
My advice to young women entering the industry is to treat everyone with respect and kindness, regardless of their background, position, or financial status. Every person deserves to be valued and treated with dignity.
04What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?
One of the biggest challenges I faced was ensuring the facility had proper air conditioning and the amenities needed to create a comfortable experience. I’m proud that Pickle & Pen has evolved into a beautiful, welcoming club with air conditioning, towels, and thoughtful amenities for everyone.
05What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?
Family and friends are the most important values in my life. I also value connection and hospitality, which I enjoy expressing through cooking and hosting others.
Join Influential Women and start making an impact. Register now.