Her Story
About Melissa
Melissa Collins is an Associate Partner and Sales Executive at Shepherd Insurance in Tucson, Arizona, bringing more than 21 years of experience to the insurance industry. She began her career by answering phones at an insurance agency and gradually learned the business from the ground up, earning her insurance license and taking on increasingly greater responsibilities. After spending 17 years with the agency that was ultimately acquired by Shepherd Insurance, she advanced through roles including office management and sales before becoming an Associate Partner in 2026. Her professional experience encompasses insurance sales, client relationship management, property and casualty insurance, life and health insurance, and account management.
Throughout her career, Melissa has placed a strong emphasis on relationships, collaboration, mentorship, and client service. She credits mentors and members of the Shepherd Insurance leadership team with helping shape her professional growth and believes strongly in paying that support forward. She participates in mentoring young women and interns, encouraging them to recognize their strengths, seek guidance, ask questions, and pursue opportunities without allowing fear of rejection to hold them back. She views empathy, communication, persistence, and genuine listening as valuable strengths in an industry built around relationships.
Outside of her professional career, Melissa is deeply committed to family and community service. She identifies being a mother as her number-one passion and believes that integrity, trust, compassion, teamwork, perseverance, authenticity, and service should guide both professional and personal life. Through Be the Light Ministries, she supports initiatives including toy drives and golf events benefiting children who have lost a parent to overdose or addiction, and she also volunteers with the Gospel Rescue Mission. Melissa's journey from an entry-level agency position to Associate Partner reflects her belief that consistent learning, hard work, meaningful relationships, and persistence can create opportunities for long-term professional growth.
Her Interview
Ten minutes with Melissa
01What do you attribute your success to?
I attribute my success to drive, compassion, persistence, and a team-first mindset. I have always been willing to learn, ask questions, build relationships, and take advantage of opportunities as they arise. My career began at the front desk of an insurance agency, and I worked my way through the business by learning, becoming licensed, taking on greater responsibilities, and continuing to grow professionally.
Mentorship has also played an important role in my development. I have benefited from people who recognized my potential, encouraged me, and gave me opportunities to grow. Their support taught me the importance of paying that guidance forward by supporting and mentoring others.
Ultimately, I am motivated by helping people, building meaningful relationships, achieving goals, and refusing to give up when things become difficult. My journey has reinforced my belief that where you begin does not have to determine where you finish.
02What’s the best career advice you’ve ever received?
One of the most important lessons I have learned throughout my career is not to let fear of rejection keep me from pursuing opportunities. In insurance and sales, hearing “no” is part of the process, but rejection should not determine how far you are willing to go.
I have also learned the importance of asking questions, seeking mentorship, using the resources available to me, and continuing to learn. You do not have to have every answer when you begin. What matters is being willing to learn, build relationships, and keep moving forward.
My own career journey—from answering phones to becoming an insurance agent, office manager, Sales Executive, and ultimately an Associate Partner—has shown me that consistent effort, curiosity, and persistence can create opportunities for growth.
03What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?
I would encourage young women entering insurance not to let fear of rejection prevent them from pursuing opportunities. Know your strengths, ask questions, seek mentors, and use every resource available to you. Do not underestimate yourself simply because you are entering an industry where you may not immediately see many people who look like you.
Insurance is a relationship business, and qualities such as empathy, communication, persistence, and genuine listening can become powerful professional strengths. Build relationships, remain curious, and be willing to learn from the people around you.
I also believe in leading by example and helping others recognize their own potential. I have benefited from mentors throughout my career, and I believe it is important to pay that support forward by encouraging and mentoring the next generation of women entering the industry.
04What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?
The insurance industry is becoming increasingly complex. Carriers are becoming more selective, and professionals need a deeper understanding of coverage, products, and the changing needs of clients. This creates a continuing need for education and for insurance professionals who are willing to keep learning.
At the same time, I see significant opportunities for younger professionals who are willing to learn, network, and build genuine relationships. Insurance is about much more than collecting premiums; it is about helping people understand what their coverage means and making sure they have the knowledge they need to make informed decisions.
I believe the industry can provide meaningful professional growth, financial opportunity, strong relationships, and the satisfaction of helping people. Introducing a new generation to those possibilities is an important opportunity for the future of insurance.
05What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?
Integrity, trust, compassion, family, service, teamwork, perseverance, and authenticity are central to both my professional and personal life. I believe lasting success is built by treating people with respect, honoring commitments, listening carefully, and consistently doing what is right.
Family is especially important to me, and being a mother is my number-one passion. I also value service and believe that success should extend beyond professional accomplishments. Giving back through organizations such as Be the Light Ministries and the Gospel Rescue Mission allows me to contribute to my community and support people who are facing difficult circumstances.
I also believe in perseverance and authenticity. I want to lead by example, support the people around me, and create opportunities for others while remaining true to who I am and what I value.
Join Influential Women and start making an impact. Register now.