Shelly L Conner, Risk Consultant on Influential Women
Verified Member

Influential Woman · Commercial Insurance

Shelly L Conner

Risk Consultant, Knight Insurance Group

Toledo, OH 43604

2Awards received

Certifications · Degrees · Memberships

Degree Monroe County Community College - Social Work Member American Cancer Society

Her Story

About Shelly

Shelly Conner serves as a Risk Consultant at Knight Insurance Group, located at 22 N. Erie Street in Toledo, Ohio where she focuses on helping clients identify insurance solutions tailored to their specific industries and operational needs. Since entering the insurance field in July 2026, she has specialized in serving trucking companies, manufacturing operations, real estate properties, and contractors. Drawing on her experience in financial management, sales, customer service, and business operations, Shelly takes a relationship-driven approach to helping clients understand their risks, evaluate coverage options, and protect the businesses and assets they have worked to build. Shelly brings a diverse and accomplished professional background to her role in insurance. Her career began in banking, where she progressed from a teller to an assistant manager before transitioning into healthcare administration. She subsequently spent 25 years managing a private dental practice, overseeing financial operations, patient care, and day-to-day management for a team of eight employees. Alongside her primary career, she developed a successful real estate business, earning recognition as Century 21 Salesperson of the Year in 2023. She later expanded her professional experience into media through her work at a local television station in Toledo, further strengthening her skills in communication, sales, and client relationship development. Beyond her professional pursuits, Shelly is committed to community involvement and service. She has maintained long-term involvement with the American Cancer Society, including organizing an annual golf outing for eight years to support local nonprofit efforts. Her dedication to service reflects the same people-centered approach she brings to her professional relationships, emphasizing trust, responsiveness, and a genuine interest in helping others. Shelly completed her education at Monroe County Community College and holds both real estate and insurance licenses. Through her broad professional experience and commitment to her community, she brings a practical, client-focused perspective to her work as a risk consultant.

Her Interview

Ten minutes with Shelly

01What do you attribute your success to?

I attribute my success to my willingness to embrace change, remain open to new opportunities, and continuously learn from every experience. Each chapter of my career, from banking and dental practice management to real estate, television, and now commercial insurance, has given me valuable skills and relationships that continue to shape my professional approach. Banking taught me professionalism, accuracy, financial responsibility, and the importance of building trust, while 25 years managing a dental practice strengthened my organization, communication, customer service, and leadership abilities, including maintaining a 98% collection rate. My experience in real estate further developed my sales, negotiation, and relationship-building skills, and being named Century 21 Salesperson of the Year in 2023 reinforced the value of listening to people and understanding their needs. Today, in commercial insurance, I am able to bring all of those experiences together while serving clients in industries such as trucking, manufacturing, real estate, and contracting. I also believe that professional growth has no expiration date; changing careers at 50 challenged me to step outside my comfort zone, learn something new, and continue evolving. Ultimately, I believe my success comes from staying adaptable, working hard, building genuine relationships, and never being afraid to learn and take on a new challenge.

02What advice would you give to young women entering your industry?

My advice to young women entering the insurance industry is to stay genuine, build strong relationships, and never underestimate the value of truly listening to people. I believe one of my greatest strengths is being authentic; I take the time to ask questions, understand what matters most to each client, and genuinely care about helping them find the right solutions. People recognize when you are sincere, and that authenticity builds trust and lasting professional relationships. I would also encourage young women to remain open to change and remember that it is never too late to reinvent yourself or pursue a new opportunity. Your career path does not have to be perfectly planned. Be willing to learn, adapt as the industry evolves, treat everyone with respect, and have the confidence to step outside your comfort zone. Often, the greatest opportunities come when you are willing to take that next step.

03What are the biggest challenges or opportunities in your field right now?

Commercial insurance presents both challenges and tremendous opportunities right now. One of the biggest challenges is reaching prospective clients and building credibility, particularly as a woman working with industries that have traditionally been male dominated. Establishing trust takes time, but I believe women bring tremendous value to the insurance industry through empathy, communication, attention to detail, and active listening. Clients are trusting us with important decisions that can have a significant impact on their businesses, so taking the time to understand their concerns and build genuine relationships is essential. I see a great opportunity to differentiate myself by being authentic, responsive, and focused on helping clients find solutions that truly fit their needs.

04What values are most important to you in your work and personal life?

The values that are most important to me are family, compassion, resilience, and giving back to the community. Supporting others has always been meaningful to me, and over the years I have been involved with organizations such as the American Cancer Society and other local nonprofits. My daughter experienced leukemia as a child, so continuing to support the Blood Cancer United, American Cancer Society and organizing golf outings that raise funds to help children affected by cancer are especially important to me. I value being able to use my professional relationships and connections within the community to support causes that make a meaningful difference. Outside of work, my family remains at the center of my life, and I cherish spending quality time with them and appreciating the moments that extend beyond career and business. I have also learned the importance of resilience, patience, and taking care of myself, particularly through the experience of recovering from a recent hip replacement. These experiences have reminded me to slow down, appreciate the people around me, and stay focused on what truly matters in life.

Join Influential Women and start making an impact. Register now.