An American Chronicle of Catastrophe (part II)
Understanding the roots of America's bloodiest conflict through travel and education.
An American Exegesis: The Years 1791-1861
Welcome back, everyone, to Brooke In The Air Travel!
Today, we're diving into Part II of our historical evaluation series. Part I, if you recall, explored the foundations of the United States and answered the question of why the U.S. won the rebellion of 1776. You might ask, "What does this have to do with travel?" That's a fair question, but the answer is simply, "Everything."
You see, part of enjoying travel is opening your mind, seeing the world from a different perspective, and embracing different cultures, attitudes, ways of thinking, and even different knowledge bases.
I will always be thankful for the combination of travel opportunities and advanced education that helps me understand the world. I see increasingly closed-minded ideologies taking power around the world, and it worries me greatly. You can look at this documentation series as a way to prepare yourself mentally for global travel.
We'll start with a timeline of events, just as we did last time, and end Part II with the opening shots of the American Civil War. Before we go further, it is important to understand that the ultimate cause, the casus belli (Latin for "cause of conflict"), of the American Civil War was the practice, preservation, and expansion of chattel slavery. Southern sympathizers will tell you the war was fought over states' rights, which is part of the Lost Cause narrative. We'll dive into that myth in Part III, but even the vice president of the Confederacy, Alexander Stephens, proudly said the war was about slavery.
In his so-called Cornerstone Address in Savannah, Georgia, in 1861, Stephens proudly declared (and I quote directly here) that the Confederate government's foundations were laid and its "cornerstone" rested upon what he called the "great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery-subordination to the superior race-is his natural and normal condition."
We, of course, know that there is no such "truth" and that Stephens's statement is an utter fallacy. But how, then, can there be any doubt about the cause of the Civil War?
Because many white Southerners believed in his address and, more pointedly, Southern sympathizers will champion the Lost Cause narrative of taxation and unfair treatment of the Southern states.
States were added to the Union based on their "free" or "slave" state statuses in what became a long game of "kick the can," as both sides, abolitionist and pro-slavery, tried to outdo one another for the sake of legislative power in Congress. How did slavery become an issue?
Well, if you think back to Part I of my historical article series, you'll recall that the South was utterly devastated by the rebellion in that theater of war. Those states largely relied on enslaved labor to support their agricultural-based economies. They were not as industrialized as the North.
There remained four so-called "Border States" in the pre-Civil War and Civil War eras: Delaware, Kentucky, Maryland, and Missouri.
- Delaware had the smallest enslaved population in the nation but legally protected the institution until the end of the war and the passage of the 13th Amendment in 1865.
- Maryland finally outlawed slavery within the state through a new state constitution in November 1864, but only after the tide of war had decisively turned against the South.
- Kentucky maintained a neutral-turned-Union alignment throughout the brutal conflict. Although it remained loyal to the Union, it was notoriously friendly to slave-holding states.
- Missouri was technically dominated by bitter internal guerrilla warfare but remained under the Union's framework, although authorities often looked the other way under the federal Fugitive Slave Act.
Timeline of Key Events
1791 - The Bill of Rights was officially ratified by Congress. Vermont was admitted to the Union as the 14th state and the first state admitted after the American Rebellion. Vermont entered as a "free" state.
1792 - Kentucky was added as a slave-holding state, expressly protecting chattel slavery in its state constitution. It would not be the last. In the Virginia Compact of 1791, it was stipulated that the status of enslaved people brought over the Appalachian Mountains could not be disturbed as Kentucky achieved statehood, since Kentucky was originally part of Virginia's territory.
1796 - Tennessee soon followed Kentucky. Just as Kentucky was originally part of Virginia, Tennessee was part of western North Carolina, and a similar arrangement was made with North Carolina not to disturb the chattel status of enslaved people there.
1803 - Ohio was admitted as a "free" state. It would become famously known as the birthplace of General William Tecumseh Sherman, one of the North's strategic masterminds.
1812 - Louisiana was added as a slave state. This happened largely because of the Louisiana Purchase agreement of 1803, made between representatives of Thomas Jefferson (USA) and Napoleon Bonaparte (First French Republic, soon to become an empire).
1816-1850 - From 1816, when Illinois was added as a free state, through 1850, the two factions in Congress, abolitionist and pro-slavery, added subsequent states to one-up each other so they could gain more legislative power and control.
1850 and the Compromise of 1850 - The Compromise of 1850 was the federal government's last resort to appease slave-holding states after the Mexican-American War. It was a legislative package of five bills that, it was hoped, would smooth things over and buy more time for negotiations. The compromise resulted in (1) California being admitted as a free state, while (2) New Mexico and Utah were organized under "popular sovereignty," allowing their residents to decide whether to permit slavery. (3) The Texas-New Mexico border dispute was ultimately settled by paying Texas $10 million to give up its claims to parts of New Mexico. (4) The compromise abolished the buying and selling of enslaved people (the slave trade) in the nation's capital, although slavery itself remained entirely legal within Washington, D.C. (5) Lastly, the compromise enacted a stricter federal Fugitive Slave Act that forced citizens to help capture people who had escaped slavery and denied accused fugitives a jury trial.
1851 - The Border Dispute. Because California spanned both northern and southern latitudes, its admission in 1850 as a single free state bypassed the geographic line established in 1820, creating a geographic and political shift that the South could never mathematically recover from in the Senate and giving the North unprecedented legislative power.
1854-1857 - The Missouri Compromise of 1821 remained in force for just over 30 years before it was repealed by the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854. In 1857, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in the landmark Dred Scott decision that the compromise was unconstitutional, thus setting the stage for the Civil War.
1857 - 60 U.S. 393, Dred Scott v. Sandford (docket, case number, and title). The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a 7-2 decision that enslaved and free Black people were not U.S. citizens and could not sue in federal court, and that Congress could not ban slavery in western territories. This decision helped lay the groundwork for war. It would be overturned only after the passage and ratification of the 14th Amendment in 1868.
1854, continued - Bleeding Kansas. Essentially, this was the Civil War in miniature. It was a period of violent guerrilla warfare in the Kansas Territory over whether the future state would enter the Union as a free state or a slave state. Many individuals flooded the Kansas Territory, trying to tip the balance of power. Bleeding Kansas served as a brutal preview of the massive national conflict to come.
1856 - John Brown's rise to prominence and infamy begins.
John Brown, a radical abolitionist, first gained national notoriety during the Bleeding Kansas crisis. Infuriated by the pro-slavery sacking of the anti-slavery town of Lawrence, Brown led a small group, including several of his sons, to Pottawatomie Creek on May 24. Together, they dragged five pro-slavery settlers out of their cabins and viciously killed them with broadswords.
1859 - On the night of October 16, 1859, Brown and his sons attempted to launch a massive slave liberation movement by seizing the federal armory at Harpers Ferry, Virginia (now West Virginia). Black families calculated the chances of such a revolt actually succeeding and largely refused to join. As a result, the expected slave uprising did not materialize, and Brown's raiders were quickly surrounded by local militia.
On October 18, U.S. Marines under the command of Colonel Robert E. Lee stormed the armory's engine house, captured Brown, and killed ten of his men, including two of his sons. Brown was then tried by the Commonwealth of Virginia and convicted of murder, slave insurrection, and treason against the state. On December 2, 1859, Brown was executed by hanging.
1860 - Brown's death deeply divided the country. Northern intellectual elites, such as Henry David Thoreau, mourned him as a martyr, while white Southerners viewed him as proof that the North was actively plotting their destruction. Less than two years later, Union soldiers would march into the Civil War singing "John Brown's Body" as a battle anthem. This was sung to the tune of "Glory, Glory, Hallelujah," also known as the "Battle Hymn of the Republic."
The stage was now set for war. Abraham Lincoln was elected president that year, which was the final straw for many Southern states, as they feared what he represented.
1861 - The Southern states began active military preparations significantly earlier than the federal government (the Union), driven by a growing fear of Northern abolitionist aggression and slave insurrections.
While the South was fundamentally ill-prepared for a long-term, industrialized war of attrition due to severe shortages in manufacturing, railroads, and wealth, its immediate mobilization of manpower, weapons, and local militias outpaced the North.
John Brown's raid on Harpers Ferry was the ultimate "point of no return" for both sides, but especially for the majority of the South, as they saw the raid as a catalyst. In other words, white Southerners viewed the raid as proof that Northerners were actively plotting armed slave uprisings. In response, Southern states rapidly expanded, funded, and drilled their state militias throughout 1860.
Modern revisionists who claim the average Southerner was too poor to own enslaved people and therefore didn't care about the causes are ignorant of the truth. Average Southerners did care, and they cared a great deal. They were convinced that a Northern victory would eliminate their rights, way of life, and everything they knew.
1861, continued - When Abraham Lincoln was elected in November 1860, Southern states began seceding one by one, starting with South Carolina, months before Lincoln was even inaugurated in March 1861. As each state declared its independence, it aggressively mobilized through the seizure of assets, armories, and weapons. By February 1861, just before the outbreak of war, the South had already formed a central government, appointed Jefferson Davis as president, and begun organizing a provisional national army. The South possessed a strong martial tradition, with numerous military academies and a high concentration of experienced officers who resigned from the U.S. Army to join the Confederacy. This martial affluence would buy the Confederacy some time.
1860-1861, continued - Between December 1860 and June 1861, eleven Southern states officially seceded from the United States to form the Confederate States of America. Their departure occurred in two distinct waves: the initial "Deep South" secession following Abraham Lincoln's election and the "Upper South" secession following the Battle of Fort Sumter, as the Confederates worked to arm themselves from Union stockpiles.
The Deep South consisted of South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas.
Four states initially refused to secede. However, after Confederate forces fired on Fort Sumter on April 12, 1861, and Lincoln called for 75,000 volunteer troops to put down the rebellion, these states chose to join the Confederacy rather than fight against their fellow Southern states. They were Virginia, which would become home to the Confederate capital, Richmond; Arkansas; North Carolina; and Tennessee.
In Part III, we will go over a couple of highlights of the war and Reconstruction.
Thank you for reading Part II. Brooke In The Air Travel appreciates your support!