Member Voices

Consumed With Seeing Flesh, He Can’t See Roots

When Branding Replaces Accountability: A Black Woman's Reckoning With Faith, Leadership, and the Cost of Charm

Baptism Being Branded, Black Leadership & the Community That Needs the Help

There is a profound difference between practicing Christianity and marketing Christianity. My understanding of Southern faith, family, accountability, and community taught me to associate Christian leadership with service. Character should become visible through conduct, particularly in the treatment of people who cannot increase your popularity, strengthen your network, or improve your public image. Faith should have roots deeper than presentation.

That distinction increasingly shapes what I call "Baptistism being branded." I am not attacking the Baptist denomination, nor am I questioning Christianity itself. I am examining what happens when religious imagery, nonprofit visibility, social influence, and carefully cultivated presentation begin occupying spaces where accountability should reside. My experiences in Jacksonville forced me to examine that distinction personally.

Two individuals who became significant within that reflection were Rique Bentley and Emily Perry. My observations concerning them arise from my interactions, recollections, and interpretations. Where I discuss what I believe an event signifies, I am presenting my perspective rather than claiming access to another person's private intentions. When it comes to Rique specifically, the emotion underneath much of this writing is disappointment.

I Expected More Because I Once Saw More

I did not begin by wanting to tear a Black man down. I looked at Rique through the lens of wanting to uplift a Black man into recognizing that he could become bigger than whatever might be holding him back. There was a time when I genuinely encouraged him to consider becoming a mayor. I saw leadership potential.

Our history included an intimate situationship that could have developed into a relationship had we been aligned at the time. I reserve documentation concerning that history because this article is not intended to turn private intimacy into public entertainment. What matters is that my impressions were not developed exclusively from social media. I experienced a private side of someone whose public presentation increasingly involved community, wellness, and Christian imagery.

My criticism is emphatically not directed toward his son. There are personal memories involving Rique that I continue to value despite the hurt that followed, and I separate those memories from my criticism of his leadership. That history is part of what made the eventual disappointment profound. I expected more because, at one point, I believed I saw more.

My Experience as a Black Woman

Rique's treatment of me as a Black woman who had been personally involved with him became difficult for me to reconcile with the holistic Christian and community-centered image I observed publicly. I experienced interactions that I regarded as dismissive and deeply disrespectful. I also felt that my perspective could be diminished while considerably greater social comfort appeared to exist within predominantly white and Euro-Hispanic environments around him. That disparity became something I could no longer ignore.

My criticism is not that Rique associates with white or Hispanic people. Interracial friendships, professional relationships, and communities are not evidence of cultural betrayal, and Black professionals should be capable of moving confidently through every room available to them. My question is more difficult: What happens when predominantly white professional or social environments appear easier to embrace than uncomfortable criticism coming from a Black woman within your own community? That is where my personal experience developed into a broader qualitative question.

I remember comments and exchanges around July 2026 that made me reconsider how I understood the person behind the public presentation. Yet I can still move, thrive, advocate, and walk in peace without proving my light through clout. My faith does not depend upon winning a social-media argument. What the Lord has for me shall not be cast down by man.

The Documented Record

Before interpreting my experience, I want to distinguish what I can document from what I personally believe that documentation means. Those are different evidentiary categories. Documentation can establish the words appearing within a preserved communication. Interpretation concerns what I believe those words reveal or mean.

The screenshots preserved in my records display a lengthy text-message exchange with Rique Bentley. In the displayed message, Rique repeatedly uses words including "delusional," "weird," and "crazy," tells me that I "need help," states "NO ONE CARES ABOUT YOUR LIFE," and later declares "YOU AE THE PROBLEM!!!!!!" My visible response in the screenshot states: "I'm not reading all that."

Those words can be examined directly in the preserved screenshots. I have deliberately omitted the telephone number because publishing someone's private contact information contributes nothing to this discussion. Additional messages and supporting communications from both telephone numbers through which I communicated with Rique are reserved. Not every receipt needs to become public entertainment.

What the Documentation Does-and Does Not-Establish

The messages document language communicated during a conflict. They do not independently establish why Rique chose those words, what existed within his mind when he wrote them, whether the communication was racially motivated, how he communicates with other women, or whether his religious beliefs are sincere. Those conclusions would require evidence beyond the screenshots. I make that distinction deliberately.

My interpretation is that I experienced the language as degrading, dismissive, and invalidating. Being repeatedly described as crazy, delusional, weird, and someone who needed help made me feel that my credibility and emotional stability were being attacked rather than that we were simply disagreeing. That is my interpretation of receiving the communication. Readers can examine the language and reach their own conclusions.

Someone has every right to establish a boundary, discontinue communication, reject reconciliation, or remember a relationship differently. Those boundaries can be communicated directly. What affected me was the language surrounding that boundary. Disagreement should not require degradation.

When the Black Woman Becomes "The Problem"

My experience forced me to confront a larger cultural question. What happens when a Black woman refuses to disappear quietly? When she remembers something differently, does she become "delusional"? When she continues advocating for herself, does she become "attention seeking"?

When she describes conduct that hurt her, does she suddenly become "the problem"? I do not claim that one private exchange establishes how Rique treats every Black woman, because it does not. I can testify only to the communication I received and the effect it had upon me. My experience becomes the starting point for a qualitative question, not proof of a universal conclusion.

Black women deserve room to articulate disagreement, disappointment, and hurt without their emotional stability automatically becoming the subject instead of the substance of what they are saying. That does not mean Black women are incapable of being wrong. It means disagreement should remain disagreement. Human dignity should survive it.

When Private Language Collides With Public Christianity

This is where the documented messages became relevant to my examination of Baptistism being branded. The public imagery I observed emphasized wellness, Christianity, community, and leadership. The private communication I received felt dramatically different. That contradiction-not romantic rejection-is the substance of my criticism.

My argument is not that Christians never become angry. Christians argue, make mistakes, speak harshly, and sometimes behave in ways they later regret. Christianity does not require human perfection. It does, however, call believers toward humility, repentance, accountability, forgiveness, and love.

I therefore do not presume to answer the question, "Is Rique really Christian?" God knows another person's heart in a way that I never could. My question is narrower: How does the communication I personally received reconcile with the Christian and community-centered image I understood to be presented publicly? That is my question, not a verdict on another person's salvation.

The Contradiction of Proximity and Identity

I became increasingly troubled by what I perceived as attention to technicalities, terminology, imagery, marketing, and presentation while deeper cultural realities seemed considerably harder to comprehend. People understand nonprofits, running clubs, partnerships, professional photography, and diversity campaigns. The polished version of Black leadership is highly marketable. Hearing the Black woman standing inside the controversy saying, "My experience does not correspond with this image," is considerably less convenient.

Diversity in a photograph is not automatically cultural comprehension. Proximity to Black people is not automatically fluency in Black experiences. Likewise, proximity to white professional networks does not automatically confer legitimacy upon Black leadership. None of those statements requires hostility toward another race.

I refuse to confuse white acceptance with Black excellence, but I equally refuse to define Black excellence through hostility toward white people. Real Black excellence should possess enough security to enter every room without surrendering its roots. It should possess enough humility to hear criticism from the communities represented within its imagery. Access should expand us, not erase us.

When Branding Becomes More Legible Than Character

I experienced a substantial discrepancy between the leadership image I observed publicly and the person I believed I encountered privately. That experience does not establish that marketing was intentionally designed to conceal someone's "true colors." I cannot establish another person's private marketing intention merely from my experience. But I can question the contradiction.

A photograph can communicate community. A nonprofit can communicate service. A partnership can communicate credibility, while a Christian caption can communicate morality. None of those symbols independently tells us how someone behaves during rejection, disagreement, criticism, or conflict.

Branding tells an audience what to see. Character emerges when there is nothing left to advertise.

That sentence summarizes much of what Jacksonville taught me.

Emily Perry and the Question of Public Christianity

My reflections involving Emily Perry developed differently. Publicly presented baptism or rebaptism imagery appearing during a broader period of controversy involving myself, Emily, Rique, and Jacksonville Run Club caused me to think critically about the relationship between faith and public presentation. I cannot establish why Emily chose baptism or determine the sincerity of her relationship with God. Those matters belong to her and God.

My question concerns presentation rather than salvation: When does testimony become branding? Social media has created an environment where baptisms can become reels, charity can become photography, service can become promotional material, and leadership can become personal branding. None of those things automatically makes the underlying faith insincere. Publicity and sincerity can coexist.

But the situation raises an ethical question worth asking: Does private conduct correspond with the public morality being presented? That question applies to anyone who publicly incorporates faith into leadership. It applies to Rique and Emily. It applies to me too.

Black Leadership Cannot Forget the Underserved

My greatest disappointment extends beyond anything romantic. It concerns who leadership ultimately serves. I have watched community organizations and Black-owned businesses struggle, including a Black woman-owned ice-cream business whose decline affected how I thought about where community energy and advocacy are directed. I am not asserting that Rique caused that business's decline.

My question concerns priorities. From my perspective, I watched substantial enthusiasm flow toward initiatives and people that appeared socially marketable while wondering where that same battery in the back was for Black women entrepreneurs trying to survive. Where is that energy for the underserved? Where is it when helping somebody produces no glamorous photograph?

Where is it for the Black child who needs educational infrastructure? Where is it for the entrepreneur whose business does not have the prettiest campaign? Where is it for neighborhoods that remain underserved after everybody leaves the charity event? Leadership must eventually reach people who cannot return the favor.

That is where my earlier belief in Rique's political potential changed. I once encouraged him to consider becoming a mayor because I believed he might understand these things. Based upon my experiences, I no longer view that possibility through the same lens. Leadership, to me, requires demonstrating equitable concern for communities that genuinely need help.

Consumed With Seeing Flesh, He Couldn't See Roots

This is ultimately what I mean by the title.

Flesh represents surface: appearance, social currency, networking, branding, who photographs well, who fits comfortably into a particular environment, and who can advance an image. It represents the immediately visible things from which human beings too easily construct judgments about one another. Flesh is easy to market. Roots are harder.

Roots are family, history, Black women, Black mothers, Black fathers, and children. Roots are struggling entrepreneurs, neighborhoods, churches that existed before Instagram, and underserved communities that remain underserved after everybody leaves the charity event. Roots are the people whose names will never appear in the promotional campaign. Roots exist whether cameras arrive or not.

That is what I wanted him to see. I looked at Rique through a lens of wanting to uplift a Black man and remind him that he could become bigger than whatever might be holding him back. Through my experiences, however, I increasingly felt that surface had become easier to see than substance. He was so consumed with seeing flesh that, from my perspective, he could no longer see roots.

Black Men, Identity, and the Burden of Legibility

My experience ultimately produced a broader research question rather than a conclusion about all Black men: How do some Black men negotiate cultural responsibility while seeking acceptance within institutions and social environments historically organized around white norms? Black men are not a monolith, and interracial relationships do not establish self-hatred. White friendships do not diminish Blackness. Hispanic women are not responsible for the failures of Black relationships.

Still, assimilation, code-switching, colorism, respectability politics, and racial identity negotiation are legitimate subjects for serious cultural examination. What happens when Black leadership becomes easier to celebrate after it has been translated into something commercially comfortable? What happens when multicultural imagery becomes easier to promote than uncomfortable intracommunity accountability? Those are questions my experience forced me to ask.

Black excellence should possess enough confidence to enter predominantly white institutions without surrendering cultural literacy. It should be equally capable of returning to Black communities without treating their experiences as inconvenient complications to an attractive brand. Representation without responsibility becomes hollow. Roots still matter.

Christianity Without the Campaign

My criticism of branded Christianity should never be mistaken for criticism of Christianity itself. It comes from taking Christianity seriously. A baptism photograph cannot substitute for accountability, and a nonprofit title cannot substitute for integrity. A Christian caption cannot repair interpersonal harm.

Christianity asks for something considerably more difficult: humility, repentance, accountability, forgiveness, service, and love when nobody is recording. That standard applies to Emily. It applies to Rique. It applies equally to me.

I am not writing as a woman claiming perfection. I am writing as someone capable of saying that something hurt me, disappointed me, and forced me to reconsider what leadership looks like. I must examine my own conduct with the same seriousness I request from others. Faith without self-reflection can become another performance.

To the Black Woman Who May Recognize Herself in This Story

Ultimately, I express this because another Black woman may someday recognize herself in pieces of my experience. She may encounter what I would describe spiritually as a "charming but demonic situationship"-not because I possess the authority to declare another human being demonic, but because charm can coexist with conduct that leaves a woman feeling confused, diminished, or spiritually depleted. Christian language should never become a mechanism through which somebody convinces you to distrust your own discernment. A person's ability to speak about God does not give that person ownership over your direction.

Watch the difference between Christ-centered language and Christ-centered conduct. Someone can be charismatic, community-facing, and comfortable discussing God while still communicating with you in ways that you experience as degrading. That does not permit us to determine another person's salvation. It does permit us to establish boundaries.

And never allow someone to make you feel that leaving a city to elevate yourself means you have abandoned your purpose there. Sometimes distance provides clarity. Sometimes elevation requires movement. Geography does not determine whether your contribution mattered.

Since leaving Jacksonville, I still recognize that I have a part to play from a distance. There are women who respect my platform, observe what I build, and may take something meaningful from what I share. I do not need constant digital affirmation to establish that impact. A like does not determine influence.

Social media can distort significance because it converts human influence into visible metrics. Likes, follows, and comments can measure engagement, but they cannot completely measure who quietly learned from you, reconsidered something because of you, or found courage in watching you continue. Some women will never publicly announce what your story meant to them. Their silence does not automatically mean your contribution was absent.

Moving forward did not require me to hate Jacksonville, erase people I once loved there, or pretend that every experience was negative. It required understanding that I was permitted to pursue expansion without asking another person to validate my departure. You can love where you came from without remaining where you no longer believe you are growing. Distance does not cancel purpose.

My message to another Black woman is therefore simple: do not allow charm, romance, community status, religious vocabulary, or somebody else's interpretation of you to become a ceiling over your life. Listen carefully. Document responsibly. Examine your own conduct too. Then make decisions grounded in your values rather than somebody else's ability to make you question them.

Documentation Without Exploitation

I am intentionally drawing a boundary around what I publish. Not every screenshot needs to become content, and not every private conversation belongs to the public. Communications from both numbers through which I communicated with Rique are reserved. Their preservation provides documentation without requiring me to broadcast an entire private history.

The evidentiary distinctions in this article are deliberate. Documented material refers to records that can be examined, including the quoted language visible in the preserved screenshots. Personal recollection refers to events I remember experiencing but which may not be independently established by the records published here.

Interpretation and opinion refer to what I believe those experiences reveal about leadership, branding, Christianity, race, gender, and community. For example, the statement that a preserved message calls me "delusional" is documentation. Saying that I experienced that language as degrading is my interpretation. Asking whether such communication corresponds with Christian community leadership is commentary.

My description of the situationship as spiritually "charming but demonic," my belief that I experienced manipulation, and my assessment of contradictions between private communication and public Christian imagery therefore belong to the category of personal interpretation. They are not presented as independently established facts about Rique's motives, spirituality, or character. My experience can initiate a broader research question without becoming proof of a universal conclusion. That distinction strengthens my voice.

I Still Hope He Finds Peace

Despite everything I have written, I do not wish spiritual destruction upon Rique Bentley. Quite the opposite. I hope he seeks peace in the Kingdom of the Lord. I hope he learns to hear His people. I hope all of us develop enough spiritual maturity to recognize moments when anger overtook grace.

I once looked at him through a lens of wanting to uplift a Black man and remind him that he was bigger than whatever might be holding him back. There was once enough belief there for me to encourage him toward becoming a mayor. That memory does not disappear simply because disappointment followed it. Some of the personal experiences we shared remain memories I can value without pretending the hurt did not happen.

But leadership without roots becomes performance. Faith without accountability becomes imagery. Community without the underserved becomes networking. Black excellence without concern for Black humanity becomes a slogan.

Perhaps that is the most enduring lesson Jacksonville gave me: when we become so consumed with seeing flesh that we can no longer see roots, we have not elevated the community. We have merely learned how to market ourselves above it.

Do not confuse someone's charm with your calling. Do not confuse someone's platform with your purpose. And never confuse leaving a place with losing your ability to serve people who still matter to you there.

I choose roots.

And I pray that everyone involved eventually does too.

Editorial & Legal Notice

This article is a first-person commentary and qualitative reflection based upon the author's personal experiences, recollections, perceptions, and interpretations. References to identifiable individuals are included to discuss the author's experiences and broader questions concerning community leadership, race, nonprofit culture, faith, branding, and accountability. Quotations attributed to private communications should be understood within their stated context, and readers should distinguish documented language from the author's interpretation of its significance. Assertions concerning another person's motives, religious sincerity, racial attitudes, or intentions are not presented as judicial findings or independently established facts unless expressly identified as such.

The author's spiritual metaphors, including the phrase "charming but demonic situationship," describe her interpretation of an experience and are not assertions that an identified individual is literally demonic or possesses any supernatural characteristic. The author does not purport to determine another person's private relationship with God. Criticism of individual conduct likewise should not be interpreted as a characterization of Black men, Christians, white people, Hispanic people, or any other demographic group collectively.

References to businesses or organizations are not assertions that an identified individual legally caused their success or decline unless supported by separately identified evidence. Additional private communications described as "reserved" are not reproduced here. The purpose of this commentary is documentation, reflection, cultural inquiry, and discussion of lived experience-not harassment, threats, or encouragement of hostility toward any person or community.

Share
About the Author Adrienne Floyd, MBA Treasury Analyst & Community Activist

Adrienne Floyd is a treasury and finance professional with an MBA from Florida A&M University, specializing in cash management, financial operations, and data-driven reporting. She has distinguished herself by introducing Power BI reporting solutions within treasury departments, helping transform traditional spreadsheet-based reporting into dynamic KPI dashboards that strengthen visibility, analysis, and strategic…

Share your perspective

Publish your story on Influential Women

Become a Contributor