Influential Women Logo
  • Podcasts
  • How She Did It
  • Who We Are
  • Be Inspired
  • Resources
    Coaches Join our Circuit
  • Connect
  • Contact
Login Sign Up

How do you pick the right mentor for you

Finding the Perfect Guide: 7 Essential Steps to Choosing a Mentor Who Actually Fits Your Journey

Valerie Jordan, RCLS, CCIS
Valerie Jordan, RCLS, CCIS
President
AgenciesOnline, LLC
How do you pick the right mentor for you

Choosing the right mentor isn’t about finding the most successful person—it’s about finding the right fit for your goals, personality, and stage of growth. A great mentor should challenge you, guide you, and genuinely care about your progress.

Here’s how to approach it in a practical, thoughtful way:

1. Get Clear on What You Need

Before you look for a mentor, define:

  • What skills or knowledge you want to build
  • Where you feel stuck
  • Your short-term vs. long-term goals

Example:

If you’re growing a business, you might need someone strong in strategy—not just motivation.

2. Look for Relevant Experience (Not Just Success)

A good mentor:

  • Has walked the path you’re on (or something close to it)
  • Understands your industry or challenge
  • Can share lessons from failures—not just wins

Someone impressive on paper isn’t always helpful if their experience doesn’t match your situation.

3. Make Sure Your Personalities Click

This is often overlooked—but critical.

Ask yourself:

  • Do they communicate in a way I understand?
  • Do I feel comfortable being honest with them?
  • Do they listen, or just talk?

A mentor shouldn’t intimidate you—they should push you while still remaining approachable.

4. Find Someone Who Challenges You (Not Just Agrees)

The right mentor will:

  • Ask tough questions
  • Call out blind spots
  • Push you outside your comfort zone

If they only validate your ideas, you’re not growing.

5. Consider Availability and Commitment

Even the perfect mentor won’t help if:

  • They’re too busy
  • Meetings are inconsistent
  • They’re not truly invested

Clarify expectations early:

  • How often will you meet?
  • What kind of support can you expect?

6. Look for Alignment in Values

Skills matter—but values matter more long term.

Make sure you align on things like:

  • Work ethic
  • Integrity
  • Leadership style

You don’t want to succeed their way if it conflicts with who you are.

7. Start Small Before Committing

You don’t need to “lock in” a mentor immediately.

Try:

  • A few conversations
  • Asking for advice on a specific issue
  • Short-term guidance

Then evaluate:

  • Did you gain clarity?
  • Did they add real value?

Red Flags to Watch For

  • They make it about themselves
  • They give vague or generic advice
  • They try to control your decisions
  • They expect something in return that feels off

Final Thought

The best mentor isn’t a guru—it’s someone who helps you think better, act smarter, and grow faster.

Featured Influential Women

Jessica Oncken
Jessica Oncken
Dog Trainer
Conroe, TX 77385
Rachel White
Rachel White
Speaker, Coach, and Trainer
Greensboro, NC 27403
Melissa Marie Jekel
Melissa Marie Jekel
Director of Development
Grand Rapids, MI 49504

Join Influential Women and start making an impact. Register now.

Contact

  • +1 (877) 241-5970
  • Contact Us
  • Login

About Us

  • Who We Are
  • Press & Media
  • Company Information
  • Influential Women on LinkedIn
  • Influential Women on Social Media
  • Reviews

Programs

  • Masterclasses
  • Influential Women Magazine
  • Coaches Program

Stories & Media

  • Be Inspired (Blog)
  • Podcast
  • How She Did It
  • Milestone Moments
  • Influential Women Official Video
Privacy Policy • Terms of Use
Influential Women (Official Site)