Leading With Compassion
How Treatment Courts Transform Lives Through Compassion and Accountability
Names have been changed to protect client confidentiality.
Kara walked into the courtroom for her first OWI (Operating While Intoxicated) Treatment Court session. She was apprehensive, scared, and unsure of what to expect. What she saw, and came to understand throughout her 18 months in the program, was that the people in the courtroom were there to help her through compassion, accountability, and treatment, rather than through the formality of the court proceedings she had come to know over decades of involvement in the justice system.
Kara struggled with an opioid use disorder, primarily involving heroin. She had been using until the day before entering the program. During court sessions, the judge addressed her by her first name and spoke with her conversationally, asking how she was doing, what was new in her life, and discussing any challenges she was facing. This program was something that could have a profound impact on her life.
For Kara, success did not happen overnight. Like many participants, she faced setbacks (during her program, she broke her ankle, experienced shingles, her dad passed away, and her mom struggled with early dementia), struggled with recovery, and had to learn how to navigate life without relying on substances. Over time, however, she began rebuilding relationships with family members, maintaining stable housing, and setting goals for her future. By the time she graduated from Treatment Court, she was no longer defined by her addiction or her criminal history. Instead, she had become an active participant in her own recovery and was equipped with the tools necessary to sustain it.
Treatment Courts consist of professionals from multiple disciplines working together as a team to help participants succeed, including individuals who are traditionally positioned on opposite sides of the courtroom: judges, prosecutors, defense attorneys, treatment providers, law enforcement, probation and parole agents, and case managers/coordinators.
These courts serve individuals who are at high risk of recidivism and have high treatment needs, specifically those diagnosed with a moderate-to-severe Substance Use Disorder and involved in the justice system. Research has consistently shown that Treatment Court participants are 6% to 26% less likely to be re-arrested than their counterparts who do not participate. The average reduction in recidivism is 58%. Studies have also found that for every $1 invested in Treatment Courts, benefits to taxpayers can be as high as $27.
The success of Treatment Courts stems from their ability to address the root causes of criminal behavior rather than focusing solely on punishment. For many participants, untreated Substance Use Disorders, mental health challenges, trauma, unstable housing, or unemployment contribute to repeated involvement in the justice system. By addressing these underlying issues through evidence-based treatment and community support, Treatment Courts help participants build healthier and more productive lives while improving public safety.
Treatment Court participation is not simply a matter of attending hearings. Participants are required to engage in intensive treatment, maintain sobriety, submit to frequent and random drug and alcohol testing, attend counseling and recovery meetings, maintain employment or educational goals, and appear regularly before the court team. Progress is closely monitored, and participants are held accountable through a system of incentives and sanctions. Success requires commitment, honesty, and a willingness to make significant life changes.
That is what Treatment Courts are. What Treatment Courts are not is a free pass out of prison, which is a common misconception among the public. As I tell participants, "Treatment Courts aren't the easy choice; they're the hard choice. Prison is the easy choice. You go in, get three meals and a place to stay every day, then come out with the same mentality, doing the same things over and over. Nothing changes. We are here to help you change what you do, how you do it, and support you on the path to recovery."
More than 4,000 Treatment Courts operate across the United States, including Adult Drug Courts, OWI/DUI Treatment Courts, Opioid Treatment Courts, Tribal Healing to Wellness Courts, Veterans Treatment Courts, Mental Health Treatment Courts, and Family Drug Treatment Courts. A focus on treatment rather than incarceration is key to their success, not only for participants but also for the communities they serve. Since 1989, Treatment Courts have served more than 1.5 million participants.
Beyond reducing recidivism, Treatment Courts also strengthen communities. Children are reunited with parents, employers retain valuable workers, and fewer public resources are spent cycling individuals through jails, courts, and emergency services. Every successful participant represents not only a personal victory but also a safer and healthier community. The positive effects often extend well beyond the individual participant, impacting families for generations.
Here in Wisconsin, Treatment Courts operate in 61 of 72 counties and six Tribal Nations. The Wisconsin Department of Justice provides funding for some of these courts, as well as for approximately half of the Tribal Nations that operate Healing to Wellness Courts. These courts are supported by the Wisconsin Association of Treatment Court Professionals (WATCP), which provides critical training through its annual statewide conference and Fall Summit. These trainings are valuable for all team members because they provide evidence-based education for entire teams, as well as discipline-specific instruction. Participants bring this knowledge back to their local Treatment Courts, where it is applied to policies, procedures, and participant services.
However, despite the success of these programs, they have not been immune to state and national budget cuts. Many teams have had to forgo sending members to WATCP conferences and other state and national training opportunities. While not ideal, it is the unfortunate reality many programs face.
The Wisconsin Department of Justice does provide funding to Treatment Courts through the Treatment Alternatives and Diversion (TAD) Grant program. However, the overall grant budget has been reduced, resulting in stricter limitations on allowable uses of funding. Unfortunately, in the past year, at least three Wisconsin counties have been forced to close their Treatment Courts due to inadequate funding.
Treatment Courts remind us that accountability and compassion are not mutually exclusive. Individuals with Substance Use Disorders and mental health challenges often find themselves trapped in a cycle of addiction, criminal behavior, incarceration, and relapse. Treatment Courts provide an evidence-based alternative that addresses the underlying causes of that cycle while still holding participants accountable for their actions.
By supporting Treatment Courts, we invest in recovery, public safety, and stronger communities. We also invest in people like Kara, individuals who may have lost hope but are capable of transforming their lives when given the opportunity, support, and accountability to do so.
You, too, can help make a difference in the lives of those affected by Substance Use Disorders, mental health challenges, and repeated involvement with the justice system. Through education, advocacy, and community support, we can continue expanding access to programs that have proven to change lives and break the cycle of recidivism.