Member Voices

Upgrading Our Elections

How Choose One Voting Undermines Democracy and Why Voting Reform Is Essential

The Voting Method Is Broken

Vote for one candidate only, and the candidate with the most votes wins. It seems simple, and it works fine in elections with only two candidates. But the problem is that when there are three or more candidates, Choose One Plurality voting breaks.

Imagine this scenario: The mayor is running for reelection after a disastrous term, and for the good of the city, we need to vote him out of office. It's time to hold him accountable, and polls show that the majority is in agreement. The candidate running against him is fantastic, and it seems clear that the mayor's days are numbered. But then another amazing candidate declares for office as well. Having good options to choose from should be a good thing, but you know that unless voters come together around one candidate, you'll risk splitting the vote.

When voters aren't able to show that they prefer all the candidates on their side, majority factions can easily get divided and conquered. The more candidates on your side, the more you're at a disadvantage. It's a design flaw in the system itself, and the implications are disastrous.

In order to prevent this clearly undemocratic outcome, voters must be strategic and vote as a single, cohesive block. The incentive is to vote for the "lesser evil" candidate on your side who seems the most electable and not vote for potential "spoilers," even when that means not voting for your favorite.

The fear of vote-splitting and the spoiler effect has a powerful impact on voter behavior and gives a huge advantage to those deemed most electable, who, in practice, are usually those who raised the most money, incumbents, and those with the best name recognition.

The incentives to vote strategically are massive, and the risks of not doing so are potentially catastrophic, so the electability bias quickly becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Politicos use the spoiler effect as justification for why newer candidates should wait their turn, and aspiring candidates face strong pressures not to run against politicians with whom they may need to work in the future. Candidates who don't fall in line risk being branded a spoiler before their career has even begun. The result is a glass ceiling that keeps incumbents in power a remarkable percentage of the time.

But it gets worse. Dark money super PACs often encourage and fund spoiler candidates on the opposing side, hoping to throw the election in favor of their candidate. The spoiler effect makes elections gameable, and those who play the game best are more likely to win.

While voters may feel like they have a choice, the reality is that elections under Choose One Voting are often an exercise in manufactured consent rather than true representation or political accountability.

The data is clear. According to the most comprehensive study on the subject to date, from Princeton University, "The preferences of the average American appear to have only a minuscule, near-zero, statistically non-significant impact upon public policy."

"The fact is that... the [Choose One] voting method we use in most of the English-speaking world is absolutely horrible, and there is reason to believe that reforming it would substantially alleviate much political dysfunction and suffering."

Dr. Jameson Quinn, PhD in Statistics, Harvard.

Representation, Primaries, and the Influence of Money in Politics

In order to achieve fair representation in politics, candidates need a level playing field where they can run and win. Incumbents and established politicians in general are often wealthy, older, white, and male. Even if voters want to change that, the system itself creates a glass ceiling for everyone else through the spoiler effect.

Studies on the demographics of elected officials in the United States show that white men held 62% of elected offices in 2019, despite comprising only 30 percent of the population. The reality is that voting methods that give a strong advantage to those who are deemed most electable will continue to uphold serious disparities in representation, regardless of public opinion.

Changing this will require replacing many of these incumbents with new candidates who have never held public office. Unfortunately, the harsh reality is that Choose One voting and the spoiler effect uphold the status quo. New candidates face very strong incentives not to run in the first place and, regardless of their qualifications, face numerous barriers to getting elected.

Challenging an incumbent from your party is a big taboo, and breaking that taboo, especially if a new candidate does end up being a spoiler, often means that candidate will be effectively blacklisted in the future. Those looking to run for office are often told to wait their turn and run for a rare winnable seat with no incumbent, but those seats are often even more competitive, and the establishment nod and endorsements needed to run for these seats go to those with all the right connections.

"I don't care who does the electing as long as I get to do the nominating."

—Boss Tweed

Low-Turnout Elections

Voter turnout is another key factor in whether or not elections yield representative outcomes. Though the 2020 U.S. presidential election had a record turnout, 37.2% of eligible voters did not cast a ballot. While every election is different, the trends are consistent. Potential voters who aren't inspired by anybody on the ballot are much less likely to vote.

Primaries and special elections notoriously have even lower turnout than general elections, and this is exploitable to game the system. Under the current system, campaigns need a certain "win number" of votes to get elected. The higher the win number, by percentage of the population, the more representative an election will be, but the lower the win number, the easier it is to win. Maneuvering to lower the win number for a given election is thus a major incentive for campaigns. Low-turnout primaries mean win numbers much lower than those in general elections. This reality incentivizes voter disenfranchisement.

Historically, all sorts of measures have been taken to suppress voter turnout, both blatantly and more insidiously. Choose One voting encourages campaigns to focus on getting out the vote for their voters specifically while keeping turnout for the opposition low.

In most nonpartisan elections, if a candidate gets a majority in the primary, there's no general election at all, or the candidate is the only name on the ballot in November. In partisan races, unless it's a swing state or district, the winner of the primary is almost guaranteed to win the general election, so the race is effectively over after the primary, even if only a fraction of the voters were paying attention.

Compounding this is the well-known fact that primary voter demographics are consistently older, more resistant to change, and less diverse than those of voters in general elections. Across the board, decisions made in primaries are less representative than decisions made in general elections.

Choose One Partisan Elections and the Two-Party System

In Choose One partisan general elections, only the two major party candidates are viable. Minor parties are almost certainly spoilers, as history has proven time and time again. The spoiler effect creates and enforces the two-party system.

In the U.S., as of October 2020, 36% of Americans identified as independent, more than either major party. But in practice, swing voters, independents, and third-party voters have no substantive voice in elections where only two viable candidates make it to the general election. Discounting the voices of well over one-third of the electorate means that partisan primaries often fail to advance candidates with broad enough support to represent the majority of voters in the general election.

The two-party system may not seem like a big problem for those who honestly do prefer the frontrunner on their side, but the reality is that any election at any time can be thrown by a small number of third-party voters. Voters who don't like either major party nominee have to fall in line and vote for the lesser of two evils, or they risk wasting their vote and being scapegoated.

When an election is spoiled and a candidate is elected without a majority mandate, that means that even a majority of voters in opposition will be unable to vote that candidate out if needed. For this reason, vote-splitting stands directly in the way of accountability and our ability to remove corrupt politicians when needed.

Top-Two Elections Exclude Voters

Vote-splitting can only happen with more than two candidates in the race, and elections with only two candidates ensure a majority-preferred winner. So, it stands to reason that many elections would allow only two candidates in the general election. Enter the nonpartisan "Jungle Primary" and Top-Two general election system. In these elections, the two candidates with the most votes in the primary election appear on the ballot in the general election, regardless of political party.

In the general election, this variety of Choose One voting appears to solve a number of problems, including the spoiler effect. In nonpartisan general elections, it also ensures that states or districts dominated by one party will usually have competitive general elections. But the reality is that these problems aren't actually solved; they are just moved to the primary, where some of these problems are magnified.

Primaries and Polarizing Outcomes

The more candidates in a race, the more often vote-splitting will cause a spoiled election with Choose One voting. Nonpartisan primaries are more likely to have more candidates, making spoilers even more common. These types of elections often attract a number of candidates with platforms geared toward the majority of voters, as well as a couple of candidates who are more fringe. The majority-preferred candidates on each side can thus split the vote, electing the polarizing fringe candidates who stand out from the rest. In general elections, the spoiler effect entrenches two-party domination and gives an advantage to "electable establishment centrist" types. In primaries, the impact of the spoiler effect is to advantage the most polarizing fringe candidates.

Another concern is whether partisan primaries consistently elect the candidates who best represent their parties. Often, fields of candidates in a partisan primary will include multiple candidates running on platforms that represent the issues most important to the bulk of voters in that party, and there will be one candidate running on a platform that is not representative but stands apart and is clearly distinct from the others. Unfortunately, as we know, vote-splitting strongly favors the side with fewer candidates. For this reason, a party primary can, and often does, fail to advance the candidate who best represents the party, particularly in races without clear frontrunners.

The 2016 Republican Presidential Primary and the 2020 Democratic Presidential Primary were both modern examples of elections with very large fields of candidates and no clear frontrunners. In the 2016 Republican Primary, the bulk of the candidates were from the political establishment, and outsider candidate Donald Trump was able to win with well under a majority of votes. In the 2020 Democratic Primary, the bulk of the candidates ran on platforms that were quite progressive and focused on major systemic change. Biden stood apart from the pack as the establishment pick who promised that "Nothing would fundamentally change" if he were elected. In both cases, the candidate who won was the one who established themselves as different from the rest, rather than the candidate who represented the political center of their party's base.

Hate and Fear-Mongering in Modern Elections

In Choose One voting and the two-party system, the winning strategy for candidates will always be to set themselves apart from the other side. Us-against-them is king. Of course, not all candidates will choose to succumb to the pressure to demonize the other, but this system upholds fear as one of the strongest tools that can be leveraged against the modern voter. It is a race to the bottom in which the political forces at play ensure that truly representative candidates don't usually make it to the general election. In 2016, candidate Hillary Clinton managed to rally her base around the promise of the first female president, and Donald Trump rallied his with an anti-establishment message. But the reality was that both had historically low favorability ratings. Not surprisingly, the media on both sides mostly hammered home the battle cry to vote against the other side rather than focusing campaigns on voting for something voters were truly excited about.

The Voting Method Is the Problem; Voting Reform Is the Solution

The Equal Vote Coalition, a nonpartisan nonprofit focused on voting reform, has identified five overarching pillars that need to be maximized for better voting, healthy political discourse, and fair representation: Equality, Honesty, Accuracy, Simplicity, and Expressiveness.

Equal: Does not put some types of voters at an unfair advantage. Voting methods that ensure an equally weighted vote eliminate vote-splitting and the spoiler effect by definition. Voting methods that eliminate incentives to strategically vote for those who are deemed more electable are required to eliminate other implicit biases.

Honest: Safe to vote your conscience; strategic voting is not incentivized. When voters face strong incentives to vote strategically, there is no way to know if ballots cast even represent what the voters truly wanted.

Accurate: Winners are representative and accurately reflect the will of the people. Election accuracy is assessed using a variety of metrics, including Voter Satisfaction Efficiency.

Simple: Easy to understand, easy to tabulate, easy to implement, and easy to audit.

Expressive: Voters are able to express their full, nuanced opinions.

STAR Voting is the reform that best delivers on these goals. Learn more about STAR Voting here.

Share
About the Author Sara Wolk Executive Director, Equal Vote Coalition

I am the Executive Director of the Equal Vote Coalition, where I have served since February 2019 in Eugene, Oregon, leading the organization behind STAR Voting, an innovative voting method for more fair and representative elections. STAR Voting uses a five-star ballot that lets voters show their preference order and level of support, eliminating vote-splitting and the spoiler effect, empowering voters, and…

Share your perspective

Publish your story on Influential Women

Become a Contributor